Weighing the pros and cons of a Patriots tank in to end 2026

Weighing the pros and cons of a Patriots tank in to end 2026

New England Patriots

The Patriots’ best path moving forward might be to extract the most value out of its 2027 first-round pick.

The Patriots are on the ropes after Drake Maye suffered an injury last weekend. AP Photo/Doug Murray

COMMENTARY

A 2026 Patriots season that started with so much promise is now teetering on the brink of collapse.

While Mike Vrabel’s club can finally rest this upcoming weekend during a long-awaited bye, a brief respite doesn’t exactly remedy the looming woes threatening to splinter New England’s current campaign.​

Drake Maye’s health and the possibility that New England’s star QB might miss the remainder of the season with an ankle injury would all but scuttle any hopes of another improbable playoff run in Foxborough this winter, while several other injuries have New England’s already laboring offense stuck in neutral.

Amid that adversity, Patriots veteran safety Kevin Byard stressed that a 5-5 New England team has to steel itself before a daunting stretch run.

“I mean, that’s the reality,” Byard said on WEEI. “Like at the end of the day, our quarterback’s out. He’s probably going to be out for the rest of the season. And the reality of the situation is, is that we’re going to have to get behind Tommy Two Chains [Tommy DeVito] at the end of the day. And you know, we’re all going to have to do more, myself included.”​

​A return to the postseason doesn’t appear to be in the cards for New England, especially if Maye is sidelined.

​As such, is the best path moving forward for New England this season to simply pack things in, rest several ailing players, and look to 2027?

Let’s run through some of the pros and cons of a late-season tank with seven games left on the regular-season docket.

PRO: They need all the help they can get with a high draft pick

If Maye’s injury is the straw that breaks the camel’s back for the 2026 Patriots, New England’s main priority should be regrouping this offseason, clearing lackluster players/contracts from its depth chart, and adding more talent to a group that has underachieved this fall.

One of the best ways to do that is adding an impact talent in the first round of the 2027 NFL Draft — a luxury that won’t be afforded to New England the following year after the Patriots dealt their 2028 first-round pick to the Eagles for A.J. Brown.​

And the more New England labors down the stretch this season, the higher the odds that the Patriots can land a legitimate talent higher in the first round to address several needs across their depth chart.

There’s no shortage of areas where New England stands to benefit from adding a blue-chip talent — with the 2027 NFL Draft chock full of prospects who could solve some of the Patriots’ issues at wide receiver, defensive line, cornerback, edge, safety, and other positions.

ESPN currently has New England set to finish with the 13th pick in the upcoming draft — along with a 13 percent chance of landing in the top 10.

That could put New England in prime position to add a player like Clemson cornerback Ashton Hampton, Indiana big-play receiver Nick Marsh, physical run defender Will Echoles out of Ole Miss, or an explosive linebacker like Georgia’s Chris Cole.

Nick Marsh with a NASTY DOUBLE-MOVE on Elbert “Rock” Hill IV (USC CB).

There’s a reason many NFL scouts compare Marsh to AJ Brown (Patriots WR) pic.twitter.com/CKrbr7rdKf

— Rookie Watch (@RookieWatxh) November 14, 2026

CON: They realistically can’t tank their way into a top pick in the NFL Draft

While New England fans might start brushing up on noteworthy prospects in this upcoming draft class, they shouldn’t start daydreaming about a future where Maye is heaving the ball downfield to Jeremiah Smith.

Even if New England was to hit the snooze button coming out of the bye, pack things in, and lose its final seven games of the season — a 5-12 record likely wouldn’t be enough to leapfrog them past teams like the 1-8 Dolphins, 1-8 Titans, 2-8 Jets, 1-8 Chargers, and 2-7 Eagles.

Yes, the Patriots would still stand to benefit from a pick around 10-15 in the upcoming draft. But New England is already too far along with five wins to reverse course enough to have a shot at securing a potential franchise fixture in the top-five like Smith.

And even if the odds might be stacked against New England if Tommy DeVito is tasked with leading the offense down the stretch, three of the Patriots’ final seven games are against the Chargers, Jets, and Dolphins.

Fair to say, something would have to go VERY wrong for New England to lose out the remainder of its games.

PRO: The Patriots have no shot at a meaningful end to this year if Maye is out

This one is pretty evident.

​The 2026 Patriots are absolutely cooked if Maye played his last snap of the season on Sunday in Germany.

​Yes, the Patriots are still in the playoff picture at 5-5. And yes, words like “tanking” are venomous to coaches, players, and personnel who still have something to prove down the stretch of this football season.

​But let’s be frank.

I don’t think anyone is expecting DeVito to take a page out of Tom Brady’s book circa 2001 and keep New England’s offense afloat with QB1 out of commission — especially an offense that is already depleted with players like A.J. Brown, Romeo Doubs, TreVeyon Henderson, Rhamondre Stevenson, Alijah Vera-Tucker, Mike Onwenu, and others either out indefinitely, sidelined on injured reserve, or severely banged up.

Unless an underachieving Patriots defense — a porous unit that has now allowed 80 points and 972 total yards of offense in its last two games — somehow transforms into the “Legion of Boom” or “Steel Curtain” in the span of a week, the Patriots aren’t going to be a threat in this current playoff picture.

And even if New England’s defense finally gets its act together, it’s still going to need DeVito and Co. to put up some points if they want to get past teams like the Bills, Jaguars, Chiefs, and Bengals in the winter​.

That’s asking a whole lot of this team, to say the least.

This might end up just being a lost season for New England, one that a shorthanded roster is likely not going to be able to pull itself out of this current tailspin in December and January.

CON: Outright tanking could further splinter a winning culture

Of course, the biggest risk that comes with letting go of the rope and starting a tank for the remainder of the season is the message it sends to the rest of a roster — especially one that is still just one game outside of the playoff picture.

The 2026 Patriots’ hopes of another fruitful playoff run might be dashed. But as Ty Law noted on WEEI earlier this week, packing things up and shutting down several players down the stretch is not what a team should preach — especially a franchise that is aiming for a quick turnaround in 2027.

“To me, that’s a losing mentality,” Law said on WEEI’s “Greg Hill Show.” I mean, you don’t want to spread that through your locker room because guess what? The players — we know if there’s something going on like that, and we’re gonna lose respect for it, because at the end of the day, you would hope that they want to compete and they want to win.

“They’re not showing it by their play, but if it starts coming from the top? What are we here for? They’re just collecting the paycheck, and like I said, I know that is not the type of attitude that Mike Vrabel has — that we’re going to tank to try to get in a better draft position. I mean, the trade deadline is over. I like what he said. Who wants to be a winner? We need to find the winners in here.”

All things being equal, the Patriots may not necessarily have to “tank” to continue to boost their draft stock — especially if New England’s defense continues to take on water and DeVito can’t get a banged-up offense on track.

And with matchups on tap against foes like the Bills, Vikings, Chiefs, and Broncos — the Patriots could still be staring at a valuable first-round pick even if Vrabel’s team tries to stem the tide down the stretch without Maye in place.

Conor Ryan is a staff writer covering the Bruins, Celtics, Patriots, and Red Sox for Boston.com, a role he has held since 2023.

Sign up for the Today newsletter

Get everything you need to know to start your day, delivered right to your inbox every morning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *