Red Sox don’t have anything left to show from Mookie Betts trade

Red Sox don’t have anything left to show from Mookie Betts trade

Boston Red Sox

All three of the players Boston acquired in the Betts trade are no longer on the Red Sox roster.

Mookie Betts has won three World Series since leaving Boston. Barry Chin/The Boston Globe

By Conor Ryan

November 19, 2026 | 6:42 PM

4 minutes to read

Boston sports fans have been stung by several brutal trades over the years, some of which set their beloved franchises back a few seasons, shuttered contention windows, and seemingly brought about a nuclear winter for decades.​

You know the names at this point: Babe Ruth. Ken Dryden. Jeff Bagwell. A.J. Brown?​

But for many fans, the Red Sox’ decision to trade Mookie Betts in February 2020 stands as one of the more painful departures in recent memory, given Betts’ sterling credentials, the continued success he’s achieved with the Dodgers, and the lackluster return Boston gained by trading away a superstar talent.

These were the official terms of the blockbuster deal between the Red Sox and Dodgers:

Boston trades: Mookie Betts, David Price, cash

​Los Angeles trades: Alex Verdugo, Jeter Downs, Connor Wong

It was a painful swap for the Red Sox, albeit one that Boston banked on aging well over time if younger talent like Verdugo and Downs developed into longtime stalwarts — while moving on from Betts ahead of a big payday freed up more spending power elsewhere on a retooling Red Sox roster.

So far, the Dodgers have had few regrets over the deal, even after signing Betts to a 12-year, $365 million contract in July 2020.

Yes, Betts — now 34 — started to slow down in 2026 while dealing with injury and a dip in bat speed.

And, with six more years left on his contract, that contract could become painful — especially if a salary cap is eventually implemented in MLB.

But the Dodgers have been more than satisfied with what Betts have done so far in L.A. — winning three World Series titles and finishing in the top-five in NL MVP voting three times over his seven years on the West Coast.

Over his seven years with the Dodgers, Betts posted a cumulative WAR of 36.7.

As for the return the Red Sox secured? A combined bWAR of 11.7 between the three players sent over from the Dodgers.

And with the Red Sox designating Wong for assignment on Tuesday to make space for new backup catcher Nick Fortes, Boston no longer has any assets on its roster that it acquired as part of the Betts trade.

Let’s run through how the trio of Verdugo, Wong, and Downs fared during their time in Boston.

Alex Verdugo

​The headliner of the return from the Dodgers, Verdugo showcased plenty of promise before arriving in Boston — with the 23-year-old outfielder batting .294 with 12 home runs and 44 RBI over 106 games in his final year with L.A.

That potential carried over to his first year in Boston, with Verdugo slashing .308/.367/.478 with 16 doubles, six homers, and 15 RBI over 53 games in a COVID-shortened 2020 campaign.

But that was arguably the high point of Verdugo’s four years in Boston, as he was unable to take that next step forward as a more consistent, impact bat — or a steady, reliable leader in Boston’s clubhouse.

Verdugo routinely clashed with Alex Cora, with the former Boston manager benching him twice during the 2023 season.

“This is probably one of my worst days here in this organization,” a visibly frustrated Cora said in August 2023 after Verdugo reportedly arrived just two hours ahead of a game at Fenway Park.

In that final year with Boston in 2023, Verdugo batted .264 with 13 home runs and 54 RBI — with the Red Sox ultimately trading him to the Yankees in December 2023 for Richard Fitts, Greg Weissert, and Nicholas Judice.

Verdugo has yet to appear in the majors after playing just 56 games with the Braves in 2025.

In total, Verdugo accumulated an 8.1 WAR over his four years and 493 games with Boston.

Connor Wong

Wong was initially seen as a throw-in in the Betts trade, only for the catcher to become the longest-tenured player among the trio sent to Boston.

In total, Wong played six years and 425 games with Boston, accruing a 4.2 WAR during his tenure with the team.

During his time with the team, he slashed .243/.304./.372 with 27 home runs and 128 RBI.

At one point, Wong looked as though he was turning the corner as a reliable backstop who could add some offensive punch to the lineup.

Over a two-year span from 2023 to 2024, Wong batted .259 while averaging 24.5 doubles, 11.0 home runs and 44 RBI per season.

But his offensive production tanked over his last two years with Boston, with Wong batting .214 and slugging just four total home runs from 2025-26.

Wong and Carlos Narvaez’s extended struggles in 2026 eventually prompted Boston to deplete its pipeline of pitching prospects to bring in Adley Rutschman from Baltimore just before the trade deadline.

Jeter Downs

Downs was a highly regarded prospect when Boston plucked him from the Dodgers’ farm system. The shortstop was tabbed as MLB.com’s No. 44 prospect in the game at the time of the trade.

But Downs didn’t live up to his potential, especially at the plate — hitting just .190 with Triple-A Worcester in 2021 before only bumping that average up to .197 the following year.

He earned a brief cup of coffee with Boston in 2022 due to several injuries, but he hit just .154 with a home run and four RBI over 14 games before the team designated him for assignment that December.

Downs logged another six games with the Nationals in 2023, but has since moved on to play professional baseball in Japan over the last few years.

Conor Ryan is a staff writer covering the Bruins, Celtics, Patriots, and Red Sox for Boston.com, a role he has held since 2023.

Sign up for the Today newsletter

Get everything you need to know to start your day, delivered right to your inbox every morning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *