Is Bukele a ‘gift’ to Haiti or a Trojan horse? Experts weigh in.

Is Bukele a ‘gift’ to Haiti or a Trojan horse? Experts weigh in.

Overview:

Thousands of Haitians are looking to Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele and his forces as a possible answer to Haiti’s gang crisis, with some openly portraying him as the country’s savior. But as Salvadoran forces set off military strikes, analysts and other observers are divided over what the deployment can truly achieve.

PORT-AU-PRINCE – When Jean Alexandre attended a rally on Nov. 18 in the heart of Brooklyn’s Little Haiti neighborhood in support of Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele, he had his brother and the investments they had made back home in Haiti in mind.

After working in the United States for 42 years, Alexandre had amassed enough money to send eight dump trucks and mechanical equipment to Haiti. But the gang violence gripping Haiti’s Artibonite region shattered the progress he and his brother had made.

“Everything disappeared, [the gangs] took everything away,” Alexandre said. His brother, he added, lost property worth “at least $200,000.”

For Alexandre, supporting Bukele is more than politics; it is personal.

“I came to support the rally… for the country of Haiti. Especially for Petite-Rivière-de-l’Artibonite,” he said, while standing among dozens of other Bukele supporters holding Haitian and Salvadoran flags.

  • A demonstrator holds a sign reading, “No to gangs. They kill our children,” to show support for Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele during a rally in Brooklyn’s Little Haiti neighborhood on Wednesday. Photo by Fredner Cayemite | The Haitian Times
  • Demonstrators marched in Brooklyn’s Little Haiti on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, to express support for Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele and his military campaign against gangs in Haiti. Photo by Fredner Cayemite/The Haitian Times
  • Demonstrators marched in Brooklyn’s Little Haiti on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, to express support for Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele and his military campaign against gangs in Haiti. Photo by Fredner Cayemite/The Haitian Times

Just last week my brother went to Haiti and the gangs “ killed 15 residents” and “burned 30 houses in the area of Gara, who did nothing,” he added. 

Alexandre wants Bukele to send a heavily armed military force into Artibonite to help reclaim the region from gangs.

Can a different president become the answer to Haiti’s desperate search for security and stability? 

For some Haitians, like Alexandre, the answer now is Bukele, whose hard-line campaign against gangs in El Salvador has made him a symbol of hope as armed groups continue to terrorize communities across Haiti.

In recent demonstrations across Haiti and in pockets of the diaspora, supporters have shared similar sentiments, waving Salvadoran flags, wearing shirts bearing Bukele’s image, and calling on him to take a stronger role in Haiti’s fight against gangs. 

  • Residents take to the streets to demonstrate their support for Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele and the deployment of Salvadoran soldiers to fight armed gangs in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP Photo/Patrice Noel)
  • Residents take to the streets to demonstrate their support for El Salvador President Nayib Bukele and the deployment of soldiers to fight armed gangs in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP Photo/Patrice Noel)
  • Residents take to the streets to demonstrate their support for Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele and the deployment of Salvadoran soldiers to fight armed gangs in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP Photo/Patrice Noel)
  • A protester kisses a T-shirt featuring an image of El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele to show his support for the deployment of Salvadoran soldiers to fight armed gangs in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP Photo/Patrice Noel)

Some have gone so far as to say, “Bukele, the country is yours, do whatever you want.”

Their message reflects more than enthusiasm for a foreign leader. It exposes the depth of frustration with Haiti’s political class and state institutions, which have failed to provide basic security after years of escalating violence.

But whether Bukele can become the savior some Haitians hope for is another question. Analysts caution that the presence of foreign troops alone cannot resolve years of chaos and political, institutional and economic problems that have allowed armed groups to expand.

The demonstrations raise a difficult question for a country whose independence was won through a fight against foreign domination: When the officials you put in charge of the state can no longer protect its people, how far are they willing to look beyond their borders for help?

A search for a savior who can restore order

November holds particular significance for Haitians. On Nov. 18, Haiti commemorates the Battle of Vertières, the decisive battle that led to the creation of the world’s first Black republic.

The pride and fanfare Nov. 18 – Jour de Vertières – brings are rivaled only by Independence Day on Jan. 1 and Flag Day on May 18. On each of these occasions, Haitians celebrate their hard-won independence, reaffirming the country’s sovereignty and its place in history as a beacon of freedom.

Given the history and weight of Nov. 18 for Haitians, choosing to demonstrate on that date made the demonstrations particularly striking. On a day when Haitians traditionally celebrate their independence, some Haitians were calling on a foreign president to take a greater role in their country’s security.

For a nation whose independence remains central to its identity, Haitians ostensibly welcoming the arrival of troops from El Salvador deployed by Bukele represents a stunning shift in sentiment. 

The appeal comes after years of escalating violence. The sight of Haitians welcoming foreign forces onto their soil, rather than resisting their presence, underscores the desperation many feel under the grip of organized gangs. 

Their enthusiastic celebrations following military strikes on two gang leaders’ compounds further reflect the extent to which politically connected gangs have disrupted daily life and devastated communities across Haiti.

“Bukele, hit them with drones,” supporters chanted at rallies.

Such expressions were shouted out, written on placards, stenciled on T-shirts across Haiti and the diaspora, and shared on social media. Thousands have taken to wearing shirts bearing the Salvadoran president’s image, draping Salvadoran flags over their backs or necks, and singing creative songs praising Bukele.

For some Haitians, the promise of a foreigner who can confront armed groups has become more urgent than the political concerns traditionally associated with foreign intervention.

But the enthusiasm has also raised questions among scholars and longtime observers of Haiti.

El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele, addresses a news conference at the presidential palace in San Salvador, El Salvador, Thursday, Oct. 29, 2026. (AP Photo/Salvador Melendez)

The question now is whether Bukele’s hard-line approach to combating gangs in El Salvador, widely known as the “Bukele Model,” can deliver similar results in Haiti — and at what cost to the country’s sovereignty.

To see a people who so often describe themselves as a nationalist and patriotic nation, proud of their independence, turn around and applaud the deployment of a foreign force is a phenomenon that has raised endless questions and sparked debate.

Standing out from the many queries and debates is the most important question: Is Bukele a savior of Haiti, as so many want him to be? Or is his deployment the beginning of a road that may very well lead Haitians to pay the ultimate price – freedom – in the long run?

Mary Speck, a senior associate of the Center for Strategic and International Studies’ Americas Program, said much depends on the Salvadoran government’s objectives and how its forces operate alongside Haiti’s existing security institutions.

“[It’s] too soon to say whether the Salvadoran operation will help or hurt Haiti,” Speck, told The Haitian Times over email. She is also a former senior advisor at the U.S. Institute of Peace and leader of the Western Hemisphere Drug Policy Commission.

“If the Salvadoran contingent coordinates with the [Haitian National Police] and the [Gang Suppression Force], these reinforcements can only help. But we don’t know what Bukele’s strategy is.”

Haitians ‘out of options’

The enthusiasm for Bukele also revives a long and difficult debate about foreign intervention in Haiti.

The deployment of Salvadoran troops is not the first time foreign troops have entered Haiti in modern history, dating back to the U.S. occupation of Haiti from 1915 to 1934. 

However, such an enthusiastic reception is rare, rivaled in recent memory only by Operation Uphold Democracy, the 1994 multinational force consisting of 20,000 U.S. troops and 2,000 personnel from 27 other countries that returned the then-ousted President Jean-Bertrand Aristide to power.

Since then, Haiti has experienced several foreign missions, including the deployment of the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) in 2004. Before MINUSTAH’s arrival, Haiti had entered a prolonged political and security crisis involving armed groups, including pro-government chimères, former Haitian soldiers and armed opposition groups involved in clashes and political violence.

Chilean Army soldiers, wearing the U.N. blue beret, stand in formation during a hand-over ceremony with the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, Tuesday, June 1, 2004. U.N. peacekeepers will take command from the U.S.-led multinational task force at the end of June. U.N. peacekeepers, 6,700 troops and 1,622 civilian police from 30 countries, will face uncertainty about troop numbers and funding while armed rebels control the countryside and survivors of devastating floods are in urgent need of aid. (AP Photo/Andres Leighton)

Residents facing gang violence continued to hope for law and order to survive. In October 2006, for example, residents of Cité Soleil welcomed the return of Haitian National Police (PNH) officers, expressing their willingness to cooperate in restoring peace to the violence-plagued neighborhood.

Since 2021, when the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse left a governance vacuum in the country, Haiti has seen renewed deployments of foreign security forces, including the Kenya-led Multinational Security Support Mission (MSS) and, more recently, the Gang Suppression Force (GSF).

Meanwhile, gangs have become more powerful and spread further. Despite Haitians’ appeal for gang members to end the bloodshed, revelations of links between politicians and gangs, numerous sanctions and homegrown vigilante efforts, gangs such as Viv Ansanm and 400 Mawozo have continued to terrorize the population largely unchecked.

This month, the public displays of joy at the sight of a foreign force viewed as a potential savior stand out in Haiti’s long history of foreign interventions.

Eduardo Gamarra, a professor of politics and international relations at Florida International University, worked as a police training consultant during the Martelly-Lamothe administration. For him, the reception is unprecedented.

“We’ve never seen anything like this before,” Gamarra said. “In a way, they [Haitians] are running out of options. Their situation is really difficult because they have a government that is unable to deliver results.”

The ‘Bukele Model’

As conditions in Haiti deteriorated, Bukele’s stature rose as a major player in the Western Hemisphere with a reputation for squashing the gangs that once gave his country the epithet, “murder capital of the world.”

Located about 1,200 miles from Haiti by air, El Salvador, a country of 6.5 million people, saw its homicide rate fall from a murder rate of 106.3 per 100,000 people in 2018 to 1.9 per 100,000 in 2024 under Bukele’s rule, according to the government’s English-language site. 

Map displaying Haiti and El Salvador’s proximity to each other.

To achieve these results, the Salvadoran government has employed a combination of military operations to arrest suspects in gang-controlled areas and community engagement efforts to reintegrate former criminals into society.

For supporters, those actions represent a government willing to confront criminal groups and reclaim territory. Images of mass arrests, heavily guarded prisons and large-scale security operations have circulated widely on social media, helping establish Bukele’s reputation beyond El Salvador.

That image resonates with some Haitians who want to see their own government take decisive action against armed groups.

Across the region, Bukele is both credited for restoring security to his country and criticized for alleged human rights abuses, particularly those linked to conditions in its infamous, sprawling prison — CECOT.

In addition to addressing crime directly and with a heavy hand, scholars say Bukele has taken other steps aligned with his security approach. Under this “Bukele Model” — also called the “Bukele Framework” or “Bukeleism” by some scholars — El Salvador has developed a hybrid system of government that combines institutional discipline, legal reinterpretation and near-total control over public narratives and state structures.

“What matters is how effectively leaders project control and competence – not how power is constrained, contested, or held accountable,” wrote Jaden Busard in a 2025 paper for New York University’s master’s program in international relations.

“This does not guarantee durability, and Bukele’s model may still falter under economic strain, institutional fatigue, or political overreach,” Busard continued in the paper’s conclusion. “He has so far met every obstacle; and as long as his regime delivers security, functions sufficiently, and operates strategically with domestic and international partners, it will remain viable – and increasingly attractive – across a global landscape where legitimacy is manufactured and democracy merely performed.”

Sandra Pellegrini, regional team lead for Latin America and the Caribbean at Armed Conflict Location & Event Data (ACLED), a think tank and conflict-monitoring organization, was more direct. 

She cautioned against seeing El Salavador’s military tactics as the main solution. 

“[El Salvador] achieved its significant decline in violence through the mass incarceration of alleged gang members — a capacity that the Haitian state currently lacks, both in terms of prison infrastructure and a functioning judicial system,” Pellegrini told The Haitian Times. 

“El Salvador also remains under a state of emergency that relies on special legal provisions,” she said. “The lingering question, even there, is what happens when those special operations and powers stop, and whether any reduction in violence can truly be sustained.”

In recent years, several leaders in the region, including Nicaragua, have tried different aspects of the Bukele approach, such as constructing mega prisons like CECOT. 

A 2024 interview with Tucker Carlson and Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele.

Now, Haiti appears to be giving Bukele a chance to prove whether his approach can work there. After weeks of reaching out directly to Haitians in Creole on social media — even invoking Dessalines’ name and historical significance — Bukele announced a “gift” on Nov. 18 in the form of military strikes targeting a gang leader.

A day earlier, Haiti’s Council of Ministers approved a bilateral agreement between Haiti and El Salvador, according to a post on the Haitian Prime Minister’s Office’s Facebook page. Details of the accord remain unknown, as neither government has released the document.

On Nov. 19, El Salvador’s parliament voted to approve the deployment of Salvadoran soldiers for at least one year, extending an authorization passed Sept. 29. The legislative body did not disclose the terms of the deployment, with El Salvador’s defense minister saying that doing so could endanger the troops.

Then, on Nov. 21, Haiti’s minister of justice and public security, Patrick Pélissier, announced an agreement with El Salvador to build three new prisons in Haiti following an official visit to the Central American country.

Sovereignty versus survival 

The demonstrations have exposed a disagreement among Haitians over what sovereignty means when the state cannot protect its people.

The promise of relief from Bukele’s troops has also raised questions – and debates – about Bukele’s motives and the ultimate plan for Haiti. That is, can El Salvador truly be the savior Haiti has yearned for to reach stability, and at what cost.

On social media, users have expressed differing views about the deployment.

Berthrude Albert, the co-founder of P4H Global and social media influencer, drew some backlash when she stressed in a video that “Bukele is not, cannot, will not be our savior.” 

Albert, a development expert who has studied Latin America and visited El Salvador to observe Bukele’s policies firsthand, acknowledged his actions as an important first step. However, she emphasized, “there’s a part of this work that only Haitians can complete.”

Himmler Rebu, a former member of the Haitian Armed Forces, argues no foreign country can guarantee the security of another nation without a genuine national security policy. Nowhere can a gang, even an organized criminal organization, be stronger than the state.

“An armed territorial presence is the job of the army’s special forces. Not the army itself, but the army’s special forces,” Rebu said. “The day we want to solve the problem, we’ll be waiting for an investigation within the police into those who are in collusion with gangs.”

Gamarra, the political scientist at FIU, believes it is still too early to make a full assessment of the Salvadoran intervention, apart from the fact that it has taken out two gang leaders’ homes. He notes that, in recent electoral campaigns, particularly in Argentina, Chile, Brazil, Ecuador and Colombia, many leaders have spoken about the “Bukele solution” to appeal to supporters.  

“Everyone seems to believe that what he has done there [in El Salvador] is miraculous,” Gamarra said. “So there is a lot of hope, but the question of how to export this model has always been there.”

Speck, of the CSIS, sees the addition of 2,500 Salvadoran troops and helicopters as a highly visible boost to anti-gang operations and a source of hope for the Haitian people. Such reinforcements can be effective if the Salvadoran contingent coordinates with the Haitian police and the GSF. However, she too expressed reservations over the lack of clarity regarding the Salvadoran government’s actual objectives.

“Blowing gang houses up is not a long-term strategy,” Speck said. “The gangs can retreat and come back, as they have in the past.”

Despite the open question, for many, what matters most now is immediate relief and they reject those who have reservations about Bukele outright. 

One X user, going by Stamara Lagrenad, said in a post that the sovereignty argument is a ruse for people with a vested interest in maintaining an unsafe Haiti.

“Nayib Bukele, please give us Haiti without gangs before we elect an anti-gang, anti-corruption Haitian who opposes corrupt businesspeople to lead the country,” Lagrenad wrote.

Lesly Victor was among the supporters at the rally in Brooklyn backing Bukele alongside Alexandre, advocating for a Bukele-led military presence in Haiti.

For him,  “Bukele is the only friend Haiti has.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *