Today’s guest post is by author Andrew Welsh-Huggins.
Good writing advice can come in the most unexpected ways, as I learned recently at an event where I was the one who was supposed to be doling out ideas.
The forum was a “meet the author” event at a bookstore in our neighborhood on the West Side of Columbus, Ohio, during which I talked about my writing journey, followed by Q&A and a book signing.
After my presentation, rather than ask a question, an audience member related his own experience writing many years ago. A supervisor had asked him to draft a press release, striking terror in this non-writer’s heart.
“How do I do that?” he asked.
The supervisor responded: “Well, think about what you want to say, then say it.”
The story elicited a chuckle from audience members. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized how sound the advice was, and how succinctly it encapsulated a writing philosophy to live by.
Here are three things the remark brought to mind:
First off, unbeknownst to the person relating this anecdote, he waded perfectly into the plotter vs. pantser debate. As someone who has tried both pure pantsing and extensive plotting, and now straddles the line between the two approaches, I value the idea of thinking about what I’m going to write before I pen a single word. In my case, the “thinking” that comes before beginning a new book involves an outline that covers around 75% of what I expect to happen, leaving me plenty of wiggle room as unexpected characters and plot twists emerge during the “say it” portion of writing.
While not an outliner, crime novelist Karin Slaughter, in a 2023 interview, captured what I consider an ideal way to think about plotting and writing:
Before I start a book, I think about it a lot, and I get some idea of the story. Then I sit down with my editor, and we talk it through. And she’s like, ‘Okay, this sounds good’ or ‘Well, you’ve killed everybody in the first chapter.’ And I’ll be like, ‘Oh, maybe I should kill someone in the fifth chapter.’ That kind of thing. We don’t outline. It’s more like this happens, this happens, this happens. And that’s a good scaffolding for me to follow.
Secondly, the “first this, then that” structure of the audience member’s advice is a reminder that, having conceived of an idea, it’s important to get the work done. As crime writer Susan Isaacs has noted, “Writing may be an art. It is certainly a craft. But also it’s a job. You have to put in regular hours and go to work whether you feel like it or not.” Similarly, you can’t just think about what you want to say. At some point, you also have to say it however you best work: pen on paper, fingers on keyboard, dictation app primed and ready to go.
Finally, the audience member provided a valuable lesson in how we define writers. One of my least favorite words is the adjective-turned-noun “creative,” as in, “Of course he’s a good writer—he’s a ‘creative’.” A creative, the implication being, as opposed to the rest of us mere mortals. I couldn’t disagree more. Everyone is a creative in some form or fashion, whether they’re a gifted artist, baker, or car mechanic. And within the context of this essay, everyone has the ability to write, especially when called into service, whether to pen a novel or an important press release. As novelist Phoenicia Rogerson has said:
It’s quite common, I think, to have this idea of what a real writer is, and to go chasing after that, rather than letting yourself be who you are. If you write, you’re a real writer, and there’s no superiority in writing one genre over another.
“Think about what you want to say, then say it.”
I couldn’t have put it better myself.
Andrew Welsh-Huggins writes from Columbus, Ohio, where he is the author of the Barry Award-nominated Mercury Carter thriller series, the Shamus Award-nominated Andy Hayes private eye series, and the critically acclaimed standalone crime novel, The End of the Road. Andrew also edited the anthology Columbus Noir, and his short stories have appeared in multiple magazines and anthologies, including The Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2021, 2024, and 2025, and The Best Private Eye Stories of the Year 2025 and 2026 (forthcoming). Andrew’s nonfiction book, No Winners Here Tonight, is the definitive history of the death penalty in Ohio.
