I Want to Have a Baby Because I Miss the Violence

I Want to Have a Baby Because I Miss the Violence

I Want to Have a Baby Because I Miss the Violence


An excerpt from Nanny Nanny by K Chiucarello

I had a feeling this was coming when Michael began texting heavily a few days ago. On the first snow of the season, he texted to say he’d had a dream about Jenny.

You know your friend Jenny? he asked me.

Jenny, as in my best friend? I replied.

Exactly, he said.

In the dream Jenny had gotten a tattoo of a tampon on the back of her leg, right in the ditch behind the knee, which I hear is one of the most painful body parts to place something permanent. Michael thought it was funny and specific that Jenny had appeared to him in the night and that a tampon was involved.

He texted, Do you remember telling me about those, about periods and the smell of rust that hits the nose when a flood opens like that?

In high school, I had been the first to teach him all about tampons. We were in his Buick when I explained to him all the chores women must suffer through when they begin their periods. There’s ruined jeans, I told him, and heating pads, long hours of lying horizontal or moving through the world with cotton shoved into you. A string. A metallic smell, I said, crinkling my poreless face. Here, I said, leaning over to Michael from the passenger seat. Smell this. And I shoved a fake gold bracelet my mother had purchased for me into his nose.

It’s certainly a smell, he replied, reclining back into the driver’s seat.

So. Michael had this dream about Jenny getting a tampon tattoo and he texted me, coming back into my life like clockwork, like he does every season.

We never could stop speaking for good, despite both of us acting, at different moments, as if we should. Naturally one of us would always announce, This is the last time, or I need space, or I can’t keep doing this, or Seriously, you know I’m still in love with you. We would ignore each other for five months or one year or three weeks, but eventually one of us always broke.

This past summer I was desperately trying to stick to no-contact, although I had just turned thirty-five in that thick July heat. Birthdays, notoriously, are traps. Birthdays give excuses to just “pop in” to “say hello.” As I turned thirty-five, it was no different. This year, Michael had sent me a very sweet message, a message as if he were my life’s cheerleader. In fact, that’s what he called himself—my biggest cheerleader—and he said that I deserved the world, that this year was going to be my year. Something about thirty-five being an odd number, it spoke to him, he said.

I wanted to ask him then, What the hell is going on with you? Are you still single? Should we just scrap the plan and elope now or should I wait another five years and try my best to not date anyone and/or continue to sabotage the small relationships I can muster? I wanted to ask him, Is this plan still on? I wanted to shout through the phone, Why are we even still talking?

Instead, I ended up saying, :):) Thanks!!!!


I try my best to go about today normally, as if I am not planning a baby. After shopping for wedding dresses, I drive the salted roads from the pharmacy to the grocery store, pick up spearmint toothpaste and AAA batteries; I put on snow pants and winter boots, I shovel my driveway, I come indoors and make hot chocolate with whole milk, I read a book on the subject of failure, I write some notes on the subject of failure, I try extremely hard to focus on my schoolwork, I text Maggie and Elizabeth and I say to them, Meet for a drink? Both of them respond, One hour.

When I arrive at the only bar open in town, Elizabeth is sucking on Maggie’s knuckle. Gentlemen, I say, interrupting the loop of her tongue.

Maggie and I met through the Brooklyn dyke circles years ago. In Brooklyn, we gravitated toward each other naturally, always finding the other relaxed in neutral-toned chinos and striped button-ups, dumping ice into our friends’ Solo cups at house parties. We were often the ones petting our friends’ hair, giving their foreheads kisses, gifting open-ended questions and general adoring sentiments. When we still lived in Brooklyn, Maggie and I made excuses to tongue dozens of oysters out of their shells on weekday afternoons, one of us inevitably insisting on another round of Negronis. We played handball at the basketball courts on Saturday mornings, taking breaks only to recount the dribble of gossip that washed down the basin of our insular community. We talked constantly of younger selves, ways we had outgrown teenage temper tantrums or long-lasting sibling feuds; in the city, we were infamous for running dinners into the five-hour territory. Now, Maggie and I live on the same county route.

Baby, Maggie says, flexing a soft southern drawl, holding their arms out to me.

I love Maggie and I love that they now love Elizabeth. I love that the two of us have found each other again, somewhere other than Brooklyn, that we are instead sitting among the depleted villages of the Hudson Valley, sipping milky fernet shots that taste like a specific hue of purple, garlands of light bulbs stringing along the fake wooden panels of the main street pub. When I am with Maggie, it feels as though I am looking at a body of water for the first time. They always feel new, miraculous, and coincidental to the specific time and place we are sitting in.

Elizabeth and I, we are still getting to know each other. We take our time asking each other questions, covering all the topics of conversations typical of a new friendship—family, travel, homes that we could never afford to buy yet passed daily.

After we take our seats and arrange our beers, Elizabeth says, Tell me more about your job. I hear you’re a little jet-setter, traveling around the world with elite children, that you’re a chaperone of the rich and famous.

We accidentally knock knees under the table and laugh.

I nanny, I reply. But I, like, nanny nanny.

Years ago, I began saying my job in double. I can’t say what the emphasis on the first nanny does for me. Maybe the stack is an underline for myself; that if I take enough highlighter to the word, I can come to convince others that caretaking is a viable job. Maybe if I say the word twice, the weakness of the single word will dissipate.

Inevitably when people learn that I am a nanny, many attempt to tie themselves to me. I’ve babysat, too! they exclaim. There’s a suffocating quality to this type of camaraderie because I know what they’ve done is not the same. Unless they have traveled internationally with the children, unless they were on a full household staff, unless they signed a contract and negotiated aggressively before signing that contract because caring for someone else’s children is the most responsibility-laden job someone can do? No. I do not want anyone pretending they can relate to my job.

If saying nanny nanny does not distinguish me enough, I sometimes shift to saying that I’m a career nanny, trying to differentiate my work from the work of bored teenagers saving for college. Career nanny flags that caring can be full-time work, that respect drives it from behind. This is a long-term thing, I sometimes say.

If I don’t announce it as a career, something I chose with my own two hands, I get condolences like, Oh, I used to nanny, too! People speak to me as though my job is sweet or that I am precious for giving my time to toddlers. They say something like, I nannied for four years before getting to my job now. They speak to me as if nannying will come to an end, a path that I will outgrow. Later, when I started accumulating families and children that did not belong to me, when I had contracts and NDAs and salaries that went well over six figures, I wondered why I even needed to note that I was not a babysitter, why other people’s assessment of me left such a sour taste in my mouth.

Lately my clients are all writers, prominent writers with different beats at the same magazine, a famous magazine that has a place in its name. One could say it was The New York Times or The Paris Review or the Los Angeles Book Review or even London Review of Books.

The writer who currently employs me is perhaps the most famous of the writers I have worked for, a film critic known for his cutting yet-ever-relevant takes. When we are out, men stop him on the street and tell him that his books have changed their lives, is he free for coffee sometime, what are his thoughts on particular aspect ratios, and how does one retain so many statistics on World War II? He apologizes profusely to me every time some man interrupts our day; he is so embarrassed.

Seems like you have the ripest form of birth control, Elizabeth says, taking care of all these children.

You would think, I reply to her, but lately my job has been a butter dish of want. Every desire my body has for a child of my own seems to be spreading by the second. It’s nearly cursed as to how good I’ve become at caring for children. My stomach turns over when I pause to consider how quickly I’ve become attached to these babies. Even when I’ve outgrown a family, it takes me years to unlearn my placement in those homes. My limbs don’t know what to do with themselves. I drive by the properties I’ve worked in, homes I’ve crowded with devotion, and I know that the locks have been changed, access codes switched. These families, they were never mine to begin with.

I tell Elizabeth, I used to work for this other writer, she’s impeccable at interviews. She hosted a dinner party once and invited me to stay, as a friend, in a non-nanny capacity, and she went around the table asking everyone what their ice cream truck order was when they were a child.

We all laughed about Creamsicles and those Sonic the Hedgehog pops with gumballs for eyes, Choco Tacos and the cheap milk chocolate that rubbed off on your fingertips from holding and warming the shell cones. That writer, she was so kind in her employment. She paid me well, gave ample sick days without question; that writer was the only writer who also bartered her skills for my own. I would watch her child, maybe for an extra hour, and in return she would give me extensive notes on a story I had written or she would help me draft residency letters. We stood at her kitchen counter while the baby played with pots and pans and we talked about a pop star she was interviewing. I would tell her about a story arc that had snagged me in the night, all the ways I was going to twist it into form when I woke in the morning. Once she handed one of her book sale bonuses straight to me. She told me, You are a part of anything I write. Any of my success is your success. I could never think this fully if you were not taking care of the baby.

I was shocked to be treated that equally. I cried at the bonus check she handed me. It felt like together we had figured out how to have a child communally. The wealths of care and generosity were traded freely and transparently. Together we understood what it meant to create art and a child and her family made me believe in alternatives. But it also made me wonder, Who in my life could I create this with? It made me want a child of my own, desperately, a child that was not hers.

More than the emotions behind it or the logic behind it, my body has started craving it, a baby inside me.

I tell Elizabeth, More than the emotions behind it or the logic behind it, my body has started craving it, a baby inside me. I was warned about this, told that once I cracked into thirty-four or thirty-five, if I found myself childless then I could count on my brain rotting itself out, that the body would step in with time bomb-like precision. Just recently a friend broke up with her boyfriend, and she told me, I’m thirty now; it’s now or never. I asked her, What if you just waited? What if you let it pass through you? She said, There’s no time to wait.

Like most women around me, I’m starting to lose my mind.

It’s the birthing part, I tell Elizabeth, that makes me want it most. The other night, my body and I were lying in bed and I was feeding it warm tea and oranges, when it kicked me hard. It gave me reasons as to why I should have a child. And I said down to it, Are you fucking insane?

With every nanny contract I’ve signed I see how awful people are at raising their own children, I say to Elizabeth. Or I see how not-awful they are. Either way, when I have shrunk myself to interacting only with children, thinking like a child, slipping my speech patterns so that I become level to these children, it’s no wonder I’m convinced that either I am a child myself and have no ability to shuffle into the shape of an actualized woman, or that my only path through this is to create a child of my own to comfort me, something I can grab onto. I’m using the word woman extremely loosely, I tell Elizabeth.

Last night, I continue, my high school sweetheart texted. He said he wants to talk. And I know that this is the moment. This is the exact moment—I clap my hands at Maggie and Elizabeth here—I’m going to be asked to have a child. We made a pact on it, that we would marry and have a baby together if both of us were unpartnered by forty. I’ve had all these years of practice, I tell Maggie and Elizabeth, all the children I have raised that were not mine and now here I am trying to figure out if this is the solution, if this will be something for myself alone, or something Michael and I will share forever. I only have so many years left before my body will make the final decision for me.

Elizabeth notes that it’s a hell of a curse having a deadline like this, and Maggie shakes their head. Elizabeth says, I cannot even begin to tell you how badly babies have taken over my brain. She says, But what are we supposed to do when kids cost so much money to raise and we have no savings to speak of? The time I’ve spent thinking about my future baby, am I just supposed to ignore the burdens of reality and continue to pretend that everything will work itself out? Why be logical about it when everything around us, this country, is so goddamn illogical? Elizabeth gestures around the empty bar.

We all take sips of our beer.

I get it, I say. This morning, I tell her, I took a pen to it. I watched the snow come down and I wrote down all the reasons why I want a child. In my notebook I outlined five reasons, starred into infinity, bullet points of how I could convince myself to give birth to something whole. In retrospect, it was a delirious state.

These five reasons, all the rationale I’ve pushed behind them, they’ve silently been following me around at night; they whisper to me when I see chubby cheeks or wisps of hair or metallic crinkle Mary Janes in the smallest size imaginable.

A snowplow drives past, and Elizabeth, Maggie, and I turn our heads at the noise. I take another sip of beer.

You got five reasons, baby? Elizabeth asks. You better lay them on me. She opens her arms wide and hits the lip of the wooden table. Let ’em rip, Elizabeth says. It’s unsafe to leave now, Elizabeth says.

I think she is joking, but Maggie nods their head in agreement. It is unsafe to leave now, Maggie emphasizes.

We have all the time in the world, Elizabeth coos. She grabs my hand.

I stare at Elizabeth and think to myself, I am going to be honest with her. I am going to be disgusting in my telling. I want to say to her, You have no idea how terrible it is that I see my life now as one long expiration date, that decisions need to be made in the immediate future that will impact the rest of my life, that I’m merely an avocado on the brink, or a Greek yogurt accidentally left open with its seal flapping in the wind. I will say to Elizabeth, Or maybe you do know. Do you feel this, too? The more I talk aloud about having a baby, the more obnoxious I become, the less I want it; and the less I want it, the more I try to convince myself back into it.

I want to tell her, No one likes to say it, but I’ll say it. Who do I think I am, trying to escape the perils of being a woman?

I place my beer on the table, and I adjust the bottom of the glass, letting the condensation wet my fingertips. I run my palms against my jeans and knuckle my way into my thigh.

All right, I say. Number one.


I was already married once. To a woman.

Five years ago, I tell Elizabeth, I was in a horrifically violent relationship with a woman. Let’s call her Lucía.

Elizabeth looks at Maggie, who closes their eyes, purses their lips. It’s not a great story, they tell her.

Does she live here? Elizabeth asks. Work here?

No, no, I reply. Last I checked, she’d moved back to Miami.

Elizabeth sits back into her chair.

Lucía was an artist, I continue. A painter, and she did a little textile weaving here and there. I suppose that’s the work she filled her time with: buying obscenely priced paints, hoarding canvases that sometimes developed but often were left abandoned.

I break to consider my words.

What I’m trying to say, I tell Elizabeth, in response to your question, is that Lucía had a trust fund. Lucía never had to work a day in her life.

I hated her for it, I continue, for the fact she never had to work. I also envied her for it. I wanted to reap the benefits of it. Lu’s aunt is a gallerist and owns this gorgeous loft in SoHo, where Lucía was living rent-free in a corner room, custom drapes falling to the ground with this dramatic view of tourists bustling below. It was a much better situation than my own basement apartment, where for $2,000 a month mice sometimes were caught in the pantry, yelping from those horrific glue traps. And yet, we slept in my little studio most nights, Lucía insisting that her plush living situation was embarrassing.

I put embarrassing in air quotes for Elizabeth, who rolls her eyes.

A trust fund, Elizabeth repeats. She sounds awful, Elizabeth says. Say the words and I’m on the next flight out to kick Lucía’s ass. How do we find her?

Easy, I tell her. You can throw a rock in Miami and hit something belonging to Lucía’s family, I say. Lu’s father, he had that classic bootstraps story. What had started out as a modest fruit stand on the Northside—pineapples, mango, guava, bananas imported from Peru—eventually grew into full-blown, statewide agriculture production. Which he then parlayed into real estate and land development. Lucía’s father, responsible for all the mansions that popped up on the small islands surrounding the Beach over the last few decades. I met Lu’s father once, I tell Elizabeth. He was wearing a worn tee that was thinning with rips strategically placed all over the fabric, although we were sitting in his sunroom being served breakfast by the house manager, orange juice freshly pressed from the outside garden trees. Lucía was the same way, always shopping at thrift stores, buying secondhand flannels and Carhartt beanies. It’s so funny the way rich people never want to be seen as rich. When I first met Lucía she told me she was the daughter of a farmer.

Just then, the bar door opens and along with the winter draft enter two men in oil-splattered work coats and steel-toed boots. Elizabeth, Maggie, and I, we all laugh.

And I get it, I say. Sometimes you just don’t want the storyline that’s handed to you. When I first met Lu, I thought she really had it all—incredible wealth, unprecedented access to the art world. But the more time I spent with her the more I understood why she would want to leave it behind, how her father’s control over her was a price too high to pay. Eventually I understood how all these things enabled her anger, how it bubbled over into violence. I really can understand why she would want to create a new life for herself. After all, I had done the same when I was younger, fleeing my hometown for the city with the insistence that I could build something better.

But now, after Lucía, I can finally say that the story I want the most is the one that was handed to me. This thing with Michael? It feels incredibly safe, familiar maybe. The “man” and “wife” of it all. These are the roles he and I were taught to cherish from a very young age. I admit that version of my future feels very nice and very uncomplicated, I tell Elizabeth. Me, caring for the children; him, fixing things up. In truth, I really hope that Michael does want to get married, along with the baby. I want the feeling of a legitimate marriage. I want a marriage that lasts. One that’s founded on admiration, not filled to the brim with cruelty.

Lucía and I, on the other hand.

I pause for Maggie and Elizabeth, take a breath before we get back into it.

Our marriage was brief; it barely counted. Lucía and I were only together for one year, I tell Elizabeth. And sometimes when I tell people that the violence was confined to that amount of time, they ask, How much can really happen in a year?

Sometimes it seems as if people are disappointed that it was only a year; there have been worse cases of abuse. They pat me on the shoulder and say, Ohhh, and they wrinkle their brows and shake their heads, or they cross their arms and stand back.

But picture something rattling inside of you, I continue, it owns you almost. It makes you grind to its will, and without it there, you’re not exactly sure of who you are, what you amount to.

I tell the people who seem disappointed with the length of violence, I say, It doesn’t matter for how long; Lucía ran her course on my body, at some point I found myself obliged to her. I carried candy to her violence, peppermints that shriveled on the tongue. I got down on the ground if asked. When I finally left her, when the violence left at the twelve-month mark, I nearly missed the rank hostility of it, the organization of it all. One could argue that the violence comforted me. It was the only steady thing I had when I was with Lucía.

I tell Elizabeth, During that year the cops were called a total of five times. Whenever I say that number out loud, when I say the word cops, there are gardens of grimaces, and I say, I know, I know. You’re not supposed to call the cops.

The final, fifth time, Lucía threw a glass at my head. This was a month after she’d already moved out, and I thought we were finally done for good. But a month later, she was attacking me, straddling my waist to keep my body pinned to the ground, and I screamed to my landlord for help. My landlord lived above me; he was the heavens. When he heard my scream, he bellowed down through the floorboards that he was calling the cops. Lucía fled when she heard his threat.

After the cops arrived, I managed to press charges, Lucía’s name rattling through my teeth, knocking around like some loose pinball. I felt like an informant giving her up like that, telling the officers, Yes, now I’d like to press against her as hard as I can. And sure, of course I’ll give you the details of every piece of clothing she was wearing when she left.

I thought for a moment before I told the cops, Khaki shorts rolled at the hem, navy T-shirt with a hole at the breast. I made the outfit up on the spot. I thought, False information. Give Lu a head start.

The morning after she fled, I went to pay my rent. I lifted my mattress to recount my cash and instead, found a smiling gap where the bills used to be. I went through my outdoor garbage cans, dumped muddled banana peels out onto the sidewalk, uncrumpled pieces of paper, my fingers massaging into grease stains, and used Kleenex and receipts bleeding with black ink. I screamed to the clouds as though I were an actor in the climax of a play. I thought, Lucía is a shitbag but is she really capable of taking every last penny from me?

Lucía stole thousands of dollars, all the cash savings I had tucked away under my mattress. She stole two months of my rent, my emergency fund.

Months before that final 911 call, my landlord had given me a knife to hide under my bed. David came and knocked on my door, asked if I had a minute to talk. Sure, I said, ushering him into the home that he owned.

Standing in my kitchen, he just said her name once. Lucía, he said.

Yes, I replied.

Has she been living here? he asked me.

No, no, I told him. Well, yes. I guess she has. I grimaced for him. She was staying here, I said to him. But she’s left now. We’ve separated, I told him.

David’s face showed no reaction. He said calmly, You know she’s not on the lease.

That’s correct, I replied.

He said, Listen. I like you. You remind me of my daughters. But you also remind me of my mother. My mother, he said, she was fucking crazy. She always had men in and out of the apartment, and one night I heard her struggling under someone. I heard banging, a dresser crashing with its drawers knocking around, my mother running through the hall. She threw open my bedroom door, the one I shared with my brother, and she was completely naked. She screamed at the two of us, Get your fucking clothes, we’re leaving. She left the apartment like that, naked with both of us in tow, holding our hands until we arrived at the DV shelter, where they gave her a blue terry cloth robe.

I had no idea what to say to him.

David said, I want you to take this knife.

He had this knife inserted into a buttoned leather case. He slid it out for me, so that the blade became a real thing, an object I could feasibly thrust into Lucía’s throat if she made one wrong move. He told me, I know it’s your life, but if I see Lucía around here again, I’m calling the cops. She’s not welcome.

He slid it out for me, so that the blade became a real thing, an object I could feasibly thrust into Lucía’s throat if she made one wrong move.

David used to sit on the stoop and smoke weed all throughout the day. In the mornings I woke to the smell of his blunts and him talking Mets stats with our neighbors across the street. He had been there since ’87, knew every movement of the block, every neighbor that passed. I thought, Lucía is never going to make it past him.

The day he handed me the knife was the first time I realized he could hear everything that happened below him, that he had heard our screaming matches and items flying around the apartment, in the same way he had heard violence in his home as a child. But instead of a man harming his mother, this time it was a woman harming the tenant he often invited upstairs to his apartment for dinner.

After David gave me the knife, I gave Lucía strict instructions for how to best sneak into my basement apartment. If David was on the stoop and Lucía was due over, I called her and told her to circle the block, pretend to look for parking. I said to her, Put your sunglasses on and tuck your ball cap down when driving past the house. If Lucía found a parking spot adequately away from the apartment and David was still on the stoop, I would text and tell her to loop the neighborhood, grab a seltzer, go sit in the community garden. When David went upstairs to get a can of beer I texted her, Run as quickly as you can into this house; you have two minutes. Lucía and I, we both thought, How thrilling that David doesn’t like what we’re doing. We thought, Hilarious that no one wants us together. We were always thinking, It’s the two of us against the world. Who could possibly understand the hard impact of our love?

The more people said to my face they disliked Lucía, or the more I even came to dislike her, the more I was intent to prove to everyone around me, myself included, that they were wrong about her. That she could be something pure and good, the way she was early on in our relationship. I stayed with Lucía to prove that I could define the word love on my own. Half of the pleasure I got from our relationship was knowing that I was strong enough to make it out from under Lucía alive. Whenever we made it past David, Lucía would immediately throw me to the ground and we would fuck on some rug or other, as if we were trying to convince ourselves that we could go through the motions of any healthy couple until we finally morphed into one. David probably heard the fucking through the floorboards, too.

It was particularly embarrassing, then, that David had to make that final and fifth call to the cops, that he came downstairs to meet the officers when they rolled up after midnight. When I answered the door, it was David and three cops staring at me. I saw David’s eyes move to the glass strewn about on the floor, and he knew that I knew it was bad enough that he didn’t need to repeat himself. The only thing I left in that apartment when I moved out of it two years later was that knife in its holster. I folded a small thank-you note and wrapped the paper around the knife’s throat, buttoned her up so David could carry her back to his own home drawers.

The night Lucía threw the glass, an officer asked me if I wanted to press charges, and at first, I declined, as I had done all the previous times. But this cop was a woman. Which I know, I say to Elizabeth, I know it shouldn’t matter, but it did. All the other officers I had encountered in the past were men. And with them, I’d really felt the hatred running through me.

But this officer, a woman, motioned for me to come and talk to her alone in my kitchen, away from all the other officers. She signaled to me with her two fingers, cocked her thumb through her belt loop, patted her hand against her gun holster. I don’t know who I’m joking, making her out to be kinder than the rest. She was absolutely as rotten as any other cop.

The cop asked me, Why would you not press charges?

When she said those words, she reminded me of my father but in a woman’s body. It felt as though I should obey unless I wanted a consequence. I knew I needed to be disciplined for having put my body in danger like that. If someone wasn’t going to tell me how stupid I was being, then I’d let Lucía punish my body until it was a pulp on the floor.

I replied to this cop, I said, My wife and I can sort it out between us. I don’t want to involve the state.

I said those words, I tell Maggie and Elizabeth, the state. As if the state wasn’t already in my house. I said those words, my wife. As if the legality of our relationship made the situation somehow logical. The officer looked to the floor. She knew I was an idiot.

Maggie, Elizabeth, and I, we all laugh.

This cop replied, You know I’ve seen your record, right?

What? I asked.

There’s a record of you, on the back end, she said. I can see everything you’ve ever done, that you’ve called the cops before, that you even called the cops earlier this very afternoon and got through to an operator.

I had indeed called the cops earlier that afternoon because Lucía was in one of her manic states. That was the fourth 911 call.

Earlier that afternoon, I had been trying to go on a walk with her, trying to trick Lucía into allowing fresh brittle air into her lungs. That always soothes the nerves, I thought. This was at 3 p.m., nine hours before this woman cop would arrive in my kitchen.

While Lucía and I were walking, she began taunting me, telling me that I was naive to think I could solve her problems. She started describing in detail all her previous personality collapses and the ways she had destroyed other people once she realized they wanted to help her. She took out her phone and told me she was one call away from ordering enough ketamine to drop her into an overdose. Maybe it was during the overdose tangent that I told her to shut the fuck up and couldn’t we take a walk without her ranting about the ways we were both failing her?

I think I stunned her by snapping like that. Usually, I was too exhausted to show any type of emotion, but this afternoon was on the heels of an evening where she hadn’t let me get any sleep. She had been talking the night before of other, other ways she was going to kill herself; she had asked if I could stay awake with her to keep her safe, which I did. So maybe you could say I was beyond exhaustion.

In the seconds after I snapped, she turned her body toward me, and I turned my body toward her. We stood in the middle of the block like that for a good five seconds before Lucía snatched my wallet and my house keys from my hands and began running. In times like these, when her actions were so swift and disorienting, I didn’t know what else to do besides call the cops. I told them a maniac was on the loose and Please, all I want to do is go home and be in the quiet of my belongings. Could they help me get my keys back?

So, earlier that afternoon, I had dialed 911 and two male cops showed up at my front door. They met me there. They were like, You know, we think you should try to make amends with Lucía. Why don’t you let her in, and you two gals can hash it out.

I don’t want to make amends with Lucía, I told them, as I stood outside my apartment waiting to be let in.

Things can’t be that bad, one officer negotiated with me. That’s when Lucía appeared from behind him, wiggling her pointer finger through the key ring then clasping the keys in her palm, tight.

Seeing Lucía and the two cops, seeing her body cooly operating next to both of them, her usual magic and persuasion, knowing she had likely approached them and gotten to spin her story first, I felt as if the three of them were in cahoots.

The cop let Lucía unlock my apartment door, and he let her enter first. He guided me into my own house next and then shut the gate behind me.

Now, in my kitchen, this woman officer was still scanning me for idiocy. She said, I know officers were here earlier. This woman officer said, The fact that you’ve called the cops multiple times means that there were other times when you didn’t call the cops, or times that you hung up before anyone could take a note on you. Which means that these fives times were simply bad enough you needed someone to come in a hurry.

Shit, I thought. How embarrassing that a cop could read me like this.

Pressing charges means you’ll get an automatic restraining order, she continued. And unless you put a physical break in between you two, this is going to continue.

She shifted her weight from one foot to another. She said, Let me ask you a question.

The fluorescent lighting in my basement apartment began to flicker, exactly like it does in the movies when a cop is pressuring you to do what they want.

Okay, I replied.

She asked, Why are you prioritizing Lucía’s body over your own?

I looked down at my body in that moment, and I could hear it nearly applauding the cop. I heard it ask, Hmm, did you hear this lady’s question? My body and I went back and forth like this often, long fights from which we both emerged as losers.

I looked back to this cop. I felt short of breath doing it, but I knew that she was right, that there was no other way to get out of this relationship alive. I was tired of letting Lucía’s body win. I was tired of having bruises all up and down my arms and I was tired of vomiting from the stress of being on call for Lucía. Still, I wanted to tell this cop that she had absolutely no fucking idea about my body or Lucía’s body.

After the cops left my house, after I gave them the false outfit description and, reluctantly, the make of her prized Chevy, I waited two and a half more hours before I received a phone call from the precinct saying they had arrested Lucía on Ocean Parkway, right past the park, a stretch of Brooklyn I knew Lu drove to often when she was having breakdowns. The woman from the precinct told me I could expect a call from the district attorney so that I could begin the process of filing a permanent restraining order. Until then, a temporary order of protection was bestowed upon me.

Later, I heard Lucía spent seventy-two hours in jail.

After moving through the motion of filing a permanent order and after I pushed and pushed to get that restraining order expanded from one year to two—Did you know, I ask Elizabeth, that typically you’re granted one year of protection, but that if it’s bad enough the court could deem you worthy of potentially two or even five years of protection—after I wrote down during my court proceedings all the things that Lucía’s body had done to my body, long lists of unfathomable and specific damage, a judge finally agreed that two years was warranted.

And even after I told my lawyer I needed my thousands of dollars of cash back, that I demanded my savings in safe return, I never saw Lucía again. Even though I was always being threatened with the possibility. At every one of our meetings, my lawyer made sure to remind me of it: If we do end up going to court, she would say, if you don’t drop this case, you will have to see Lucía again.

My lawyer constantly recommended dropping the case, as if I were the one being difficult for trying to reorganize my life back toward safety. But I nearly relished the idea of seeing Lucía on the stand and under oath, in such a formal setting where she couldn’t come near me; of crossing my legs in that wooden box on an altar, avoiding eye contact with her the entire time, telling my story straight and crass to a varied lot of strangers. I told my lawyer, I don’t give a shit if I have to see Lucía.

And after nine months in court, negotiating in separate offices with our separate lawyers, Lucía finally pled guilty and that was that. We never made it to trial. After that, the divorce was quick. There was nothing to contest: we had no joined finances, no property or children to quarrel over. To this day, I wonder what made her cave first. It was a move I wasn’t expecting—she was so stubborn and vain that I imagined her sticking it out to the end just so she could watch me flail in testimony, or ruin me with a lengthy mediation.

I received my restitution check for $2,700 from the district attorney’s office one month later. I spent half of that immediately on a Rachel Comey suit that I carried home in the only garment bag I own. I placed the other half back into my emergency fund. My check came with a congratulatory note from the mayor. Said something like, We stand behind all victims. Probably mentioned that I was very brave. Our order of protection dissipated two Aprils ago. Our divorce was finalized much sooner before that.

The violence with Lucía stopped so abruptly that often I wonder if I hallucinated it, I tell Maggie and Elizabeth tonight, the racket and the fuss of it all. I wonder if I miss that violence.

Elizabeth takes out a pack of cigarettes and Maggie places their head in their hands, palms over their eyes. No one likes this story.

Do I miss that violence? I ask again. And then I think, what is the next most violent thing a person can do to themselves? Without the welts along my chest, bruises in the shape of fingers around my throat—how can I possibly fill a void that frantic? I ask.

Have a baby, I answer for myself. That is the next and most violent thing a woman can do.

Have a baby.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *