Gabriel Smith “Brat” (2024) – The Horror Bookshelf

Gabriel Smith “Brat” (2024) – The Horror Bookshelf

Publication Date: June 4, 2024
Publisher: Penguin Random House

Regular visitors to The Horror Bookshelf know that one of my goals when I relaunched the site was that in addition to reviewing I wanted to actively search out and spotlight debut authors. One of the reasons was the thrill of discovery, but another reason was to hopefully expand my exposure to other styles. As a horror obsessive and someone embarking on their own writing journey, one of the best things to do along with writing is to read as much as possible and as widely as possible. I’ve taken that advice to heart and am always on the search for books that aren’t afraid to push the boundaries of what is considered horror and the conventions of the traditional novel. There are so many examples, but I first fell in love with that mode of storytelling through Mark Z. Danielewsi’s House of Leaves and then Doug Dorst and J.J. Abrams’collaboration S. So when I first started hearing the buzz floating around Gabriel Smith’s Brat, I was immediately intrigued. 

Brat introduces readers to the book’s protagonist Gabriel at a low point in his life. He’s getting checked out after getting his ass handed to him by his fourteen-year-old nephew, his father’s just passed away, his girlfriend left him, and he’s dodging his editors after receiving his advance months ago with no progress to show on his second novel. Then there’s the matter of the seemingly harmless eczema diagnosis that leads to sheets of his skin peeling off his body. Feeling aimless and with his life crumbling around him, when Gabriel’s sister-in-law suggests he help get his parent’s house ready for sale, he jumps at the chance to leave London. He has no intentions of selling the house, but the prospect of not paying rent intrigues him.

However, Gabriel’s escape to the countryside only plunges his life further into chaos. As his skin condition worsens and the sheets peeling off his body become larger and occur more frequently, he notices the house is slowly being overrun with mold. As he navigates the house, he discovers curious mysteries, including bizarre manuscripts from his parents that lead him on a quest to uncover family secrets. Then there is the mysterious figure that Gabriel keeps spotting lurking around the property….

After reading Brat and sitting with it for a few days, I’m still not entirely sure how I feel about it. Part of it has to do with my own expectations about the book before I even started it. When I first read the synopsis, it seemed like a novel that promised psychedelic scares, creepiness, and a vast array of genre-hopping. Brat does deliver a bit of genre-hopping since it blends autofiction with traditional gothic elements, but the sense of dread and unease that I eagerly anticipated was non-existent. Instead, the scenes of Gabriel’s skin peeling off and the mystery surrounding the manuscripts and videos found throughout the house, while adding a pleasant touch of strangeness, never seem to bother Gabriel all that much. Sure, he attempts to unravel the secrets the manuscripts and subsequent video hint at, but there’s little urgency from Gabriel for a bulk of the novel. That being said, it’s entirely possible that it’s intentional to fit Gabriel’s character and state of mind, but his reactions to the high strangeness that’s slowly closing in on him just seemed a bit jarring. 

There were elements of Smith’s style in Brat that I absolutely loved. Smith takes readers on a journey through the mysteries of Gabriel’s family through sections of a more traditional narrative structure with fragments of other stories. There’s a strange family movie, a complete short story from his ex called “Cum Tributo”, fragments of a manuscript from his mother called “ A Bit of Earth”, and an unproduced script from his late father titled “The Tape”. These interludes don’t just offer a stylistic change of pace, but they also influence the overall narrative. They raise questions about Gabriel’s family that set him on the path of coming to terms with his life and his grief. At times, they also tug on the threads of reality that make up Gabriel’s reality in Brat. How much of what is happening is real and how much is a result of the chaos in Gabriel’s life causing him to seek meaning in these works and events that pop up while he lives in his old home? If there was one thing that didn’t work for me, it was that at times the writing was a bit too expository and took me out of the rhythm of the story. 

There were plenty of things I loved about Brat, but I think this is one of those situations where I think I liked the idea of the book more so than the execution. Even though there were some things about Brat that just didn’t work for me, I will definitely check out more of Gabriel Smith’s work in the future. There were some risky narrative choices and I respect Smith for going for them. That boldness and imaginative idea that beats at the center of Brat means that while this book didn’t quite work for me, I’m willing to roll the dice that one of Smith’s future books might be. If you like strange fiction that features plenty of dry humor and a protagonist that continually picks fights despite getting his ass kicked, this is worth putting on your TBR. Just know that if you’re looking for something that’s on the darker side, this may not be the book for you.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *