Did Patriots fumble decision to cut Stefon Diggs? – NBC Boston

Did Patriots fumble decision to cut Stefon Diggs? – NBC Boston

What to Know

  • Stefon Diggs scored the game-winning touchdown for Washington over the Giants on Thursday Night Football.
  • The Patriots released Diggs after his 85-catch, 1,013-yard season last year.
  • The team’s planned two-headed monster of A.J. Brown and Romeo Doubs has not gotten off the ground yet.
  • The Patriots also traded Kayshon Boutte and kept Kyle Williams.

Anybody who’s in any sort of decision-making position in any field knows that hindsight is never available at the moment of truth.

Alas, second-guessing from those not involved in the decision is nevertheless inevitable.

And in the case of the Patriots and their offseason decisions at wide receiver, Stefon Diggs is making his 2026 campaign impossible to ignore.

The 32-year-old Diggs caught six passes for 83 yards and the dramatic game-winning touchdown on Thursday night in New Jersey to lead Washington to a win over the Giants and keep the Commanders alive in the NFC East.

Diggs made sure to let everybody know … that he is like that.

With Diggs having his best game on a national stage, it’s certainly dredged up some certain feelings, thoughts and emotions in New England, particularly in light of the Patriots’ issues at the receiver position.

The fact that those issues appear to be self-inflicted is certainly intensifying all of those reactions.

And while we all must accept that second-guessing the Patriots’ decisions at wide receiver won’t mean a lick for the team moving forward, it’s still a worthwhile exercise to determine if and where the Patriots might have made some decisions they regret. (The fact that plenty of people were first-guessing the moves as they happened makes it fair game, too.)

Why did Patriots cut Stefon Diggs?

While some of us may have believed the Patriots got out of the Stefon Diggs business because the team escaped largely unscathed from a few off-field situations, Phil Perry said it was more of a football decision.

“I don’t really think this court case had anything to do with the Patriots releasing him,” Perry said at the time. “I think that move to part ways with him was more about money owed and age, and a willingness and a desire to upgrade — which I think they think they have done with Romeo Doubs.”

Even that logic, though, is questionable. Doubs is undeniably seven years younger than Diggs, but Doubs had produced a season like Diggs’ 2025 season exactly zero times in his career. Expecting Doubs to be able to replicate Diggs’ 85-catch, 1,013-yard season required quite a bit of projecting. And with Doubs underperforming even before landing on IR with a shoulder injury, those projections appear to have been misguided.

Still, it should be noted that even Diggs himself isn’t on pace to replicate Diggs’ 2025 season. Diggs is only on pace for 68 receptions and 729 yards, though he’s already scored six touchdowns after only scoring four last year. Doubs was on a similar track for yards and touchdowns prior to suffering the shoulder injury.

One thing that Doubs — nor A.J. Brown, nor anybody else on the Patriots’ roster — has not been able to replace is Diggs’ leadership, which was a surprisingly strong trait during his short stint in New England.

In the wake of DeMario Douglas lamenting the Patriots’ lack of energy on the sideline, it’s fair to question if Mike Vrabel and the front office overestimated the leadership on the 2026 team and/or took for granted what Diggs brought to the locker room last year. A fiery, veteran leader with the full respect and buy-in from his teammates appears to be absent this year.

Why did Patriots sign Romeo Doubs?

According to Eliot Wolf, just about everything about Romeo Doubs was great.

“I think he has a really cool skill set. I think he can play outside, inside, he blocks, he can play Z, he can play X. He’s good on the short routes, he’s good on the deep routes, he’s good with the ball in his hands,” Wolf said in March. “But overall, just the competitor, the person. … He was on his iPad, learning the formations while I was trying to get him to sign his contract this morning. So it was pretty cool.”

Certainly, parts of Doubs’ game made him appealing. He was entering his age 26 season, after setting a career high in receiving yards (even if that high was just 724 yards). He may only be 6-foot-2, but he plays big when he needs to, and he’s versatile to play across the formation. He caught eight touchdowns in 2023 and thus has proven to be a capable red zone threat.

It’s not difficult to understand the concept: Remove Doubs from an offense where he’s competing for targets with similar receivers, pair him with Drake Maye, ride the success. It’s sensible on paper.

In practice, it hasn’t yet panned out.

Doubs’ drop in Week 1 in Seattle was a big one, and he told the media afterward that he “just wasn’t locked in enough” — a heck of a way to make a first impression.

While Doubs has made some progress, it’s generally been of the two-steps-forward-one-step-back variety, best evidenced by him suffering a shoulder injury while hauling in a 42-yard touchdown catch in Week 6.

Provided he returns from that injury, he should still have opportunities to fulfill some of the Patriots’ expectations that inspired the four-year, $68 million contract with $39 million guaranteed. Still, both before and during A.J. Brown’s injury absence, Doubs has not looked like someone who would be considered a No. 1 wide receiver.

If acquiring a WR1 was the Patriots’ goal with the Doubs signing, they misjudged at least some of Doubs’ capabilities.

Why did Patriots acquire A.J. Brown?

The short answer is obvious: Brown has proven to be a top-10 receiver in the NFL, he was clearly available via trade, and the Patriots wanted him. Simple enough.

And though Brown has missed more time than he’s played this season, there still should be no reason to question why the Patriots sought to add a player of Brown’s caliber.

The questions should be: Why did they give up a first-round pick to get him when no other teams were negotiating to acquire him, and why were they unbothered by the medical reports on his knee?

Even the first part can be forgiven. A first-round pick and a fifth-round pick for a receiver being chased by zero other teams is, unquestionably, an overpay. But nobody cares about an overpay if the player works out. If the player doesn’t work out, there will be questions about the process.

But the latter part is really where this one will ultimately be decided. Is Brown’s high ankle sprain/knee flare-up/sudden case of the drops just a blip on the radar? Or is the beginning of the end? (An end that the Rams might have seen coming and thus stayed away.)

The preexisting knee injury being a known issue is why Brown’s injury this season can fully be chalked up to bad luck. And there’s a genuine risk that the trading away of a first-round pick becomes a real boondoggle for the organization.

That, though, might be a separate issue from the one at hand, as the release of Diggs happened before the Patriots could have really known that they were getting Brown.

Were the Patriots too committed to Kyle Williams?

When Mike Vrabel explained to the media that Kayshon Boutte would have been a healthy scratch with the Patriots, it was partially absurd but still mostly true. It also likely reflected the Patriots’ front office’s feelings about potentially keeping Diggs in an offense that could have been led by A.J. Brown.

Yet while Brown and Doubs are the big names, the name of Kyle Williams shouldn’t go completely ignored. Because while Williams’ presence on the depth chart may not have impacted the Diggs decision, it certainly factored into the decision to trade Boutte.

And it appears to be a case of a head coach and front office committing to the guy they drafted over a player who was left on the roster from a prior regime. It may not be a classic case, as Eliot Wolf and Matt Groh were part of the Bill Belichick staff that drafted Boutte in 2023, but roles were certainly more established when Wolf and the Patriots drafted Williams in the third round in 2025.

Williams showed flashes as a rookie but only caught 10 passes and consistently struggled to be where Drake Maye expected him to be. In Year 2, he’s made progress, but it’s been minimal.

So when Williams failed to track an accurately delivered deep ball against the Packers on the same day that Boutte was breaking out with the Texans (four receptions, 125 yards, two touchdowns), the questions around New England increased.

Just as the Patriots might have taken Diggs’ leadership for granted, they also might have seen the obvious deep-ball chemistry that Boutte had with Maye and assumed that someone else could do just as well. That’s proven to be trickier to generate than the decision-makers in Foxboro anticipated.

Decision-making over bad luck

One could make the case, if one were so inclined, that the Patriots’ current wide receiver situation is simply a result of a few bad breaks. Unpredictable. Not preventable.

That wouldn’t be very honest, though.

Brown’s injury history was known, to the point where no team other than the Patriots seriously pursued him via trade. Committing significant draft capital to acquire him despite that circumstance was a questionable decision.

Doubs was not a No. 1 receiver. He’s a perfectly capable NFL receiver, but he certainly lacks the personality to lead a wide receiver room on or off the field. Assuming he could fill that role was a questionable decision.

Williams may one day prove the world wrong, but for now, he looks like the latest in a long line of Patriots receivers to be drafted in the first half of the draft who just didn’t have it. Believing he could take a giant leap in Year 2 was — you guessed it — a questionable decision.

So, if the question is “Did the Patriots make a mistake in cutting Stefon Diggs after his excellent season in New England?” then the simplest answer is yes. But the real answer is that moving on from Diggs was one of a handful of decisions that appears to have set the franchise back — at least temporarily — at one of the most important positions on the field.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *