Miami and Texas A&M have similar features: they win by disrupting you, pressuring you and forcing you into decisions you don’t want to make on third down. That’s the tone here, two fencers in a phone booth with no room to breathe, no space to get comfortable and every mistake amplified.
It’s the second game of the College Football Playoff and looming is Ohio State, rested and waiting in the Cotton Bowl, watching two teams wear each other out for the right to get there. Which team will advance?
Odds via DraftKings Sportsbook.
College Football Playoff First Round
No. 10 Miami at No. 7 Texas A&M -3
Saturday, Dec. 20, Noon, ABC, ESPN
Records: Miami 10-2, 4-0 vs. AP teams; Texas A&M 11-1, 3-1 vs. AP teams
Opening Line: Texas A&M -4, O/U 52.5
Money line: Miami (+136); Texas A&M (-162)
Over/Under: 50.5 (O -108, U -112)
Miami’s defense is real. Miami’s margin is not
Miami’s defense is legit — full stop. The Canes have a playoff-caliber unit with an elite pass rush, strong coverage, the ability to speed quarterbacks up and steal possessions. If Miami is competitive at Kyle Field, it’s because the defense keeps them there.
The problem is what happens on the other side. Miami’s ceiling and floor are tied to one variable: QB Carson Beck being protected, clean and on schedule.
Editor’s Picks
2 Related
When Beck is protected, Miami is efficient and capable of beating quality teams like Notre Dame. Beck is decisive; the ball comes out on time, and the offense hums. When pressure shows up, efficiency drops with no second gear to lean on. That fragility showed up as clear as day in losses to Louisville and SMU, where Beck threw six combined interceptions.
That matters against Texas A&M, a team built to disrupt. They can force Beck off his first read, turn third and manageable into third and long, and that’s where Miami’s offense becomes suspect.
The Hurricanes defense can do its job and still lose. They can win early downs, force punts, even create a takeaway or two but if the offense can’t avoid implosion and survive under stress, then the defense ends up living on the field.
Miami’s defense raises the floor, but Beck caps the ceiling.
Texas A&M is built to fight, not cruise
Texas A&M’s skill group will be a tough matchup for Miami’s defense. Alex Slitz/Getty Images
Offensively, the Aggies have the best skill group that Miami will have faced. KC Concepcion and Mario Craver are a real problem, stressing coverage rules and forcing defenses to tackle in space, which happens to be Miami’s biggest defensive weakness.
The Aggies aren’t one-dimensional, but their identity is physicality. They can lean on the run game when things get messy, which is one trait that travels into postseason football and makes Mike Elko’s squad dangerous as an underdog or a short favorite.
Defensively, A&M belongs in the same tier as Miami. The pass rush is nasty and the front can bring the heat, but the profile isn’t pristine. South Carolina put points on them, Notre Dame moved the ball and Texas exposed late-game discipline issues once momentum flipped. When asked to control, that’s when the cracks show for the Aggies.
The team is comfortable in conflict, less comfortable cruising.
Betting consideration: UNDER 51.5
Texas A&M’s schedule creates the illusion of shootouts. But in reality, the Aggies didn’t create chaos, they responded to it. Notre Dame, LSU, Arkansas and South Carolina all pulled the Aggies into fast games. That adaptability is not the same as identity. The move from 50.5 to 51.5 is perception of who A&M is, not who it’s been asked to be.
College Football Playoff Bracket Challenge
Fill out up to TWO College Football Playoff Brackets! Create a group and invite your friends. $50K in prizes! Make Your Picks
Miami doesn’t want that game.
Disruption drives the handicap in this one. Miami owns the second-best pass rush grade, while the Aggies have an 82nd passing grade that bogs down when asked to execute cleanly. Marcel Reed has 10 interceptions on the season, six in his last five games.
Flip it and Beck’s efficiency collapses when the pocket breaks down. His completion rate drops from 77.4% when clean to 51.3 under pressure. Yards per pass attempt fall from 9 to 6.7 and his passing grade from 87 to 53, with interception risk spiking. Against an A&M defense that is top 10 in pressures and sacks, that points to stalled drives.
Both quarterbacks deteriorate when hurried, turnovers threaten tempo and if Miami’s defense consistently continues to stiffen (allowing just 19 total touchdowns all season, sixth fewest in the FBS), the scoring ceiling stays capped. This sets up a defensive fight.
If I had to pick a side? Miami +3. This isn’t a “home SEC teams rolls” kind of spot. When chaos creeps in and margins are thin, taking points matters more than chasing the winner.
