There are too many reasons for the Patriots not to sign Daniel Jones

There are too many reasons for the Patriots not to sign Daniel Jones

New England Patriots

New England might be desperate for a quarterback, but Jones is not the answer.

Daniel Jones was released from the Colts on Friday. (AP Photo/David J. Phillip)

COMMENTARY

The Indianapolis Colts released Daniel Jones on Friday, and he’s immediately the most intriguing free agent signal-caller available.

He had a career resurgence in 2025 with the Colts, hailing as a legitimate MVP candidate early in the season as Indianapolis steamrolled offensively. He played so well that even after as serious an injury as a torn Achilles, the Colts were willing to commit to him as their quarterback of the future with a lucrative 2-year, $88 million deal.

He hasn’t looked good in 2026 by any stretch. But a team in desperate need of a quarterback could put in a claim for him and hope to bring him back to life. Enter: the New England Patriots.

Drake Maye is likely done for the rest of the regular season, if not even longer, with his fractured ankle. Tommy DeVito played the majority of New England’s loss to the Lions in Germany, and wasn’t able to move the ball at all in that contest. A Patriots team that has any hope of reaching the postseason and getting Maye back for that stretch would be silly not to try and improve at the quarterback position.

And Jones and Maye grew up close to each other in Charlotte, even training together in the offseason. So the two have a real connection that can’t be overlooked.

But there are too many reasons why New England shouldn’t take the risk on Jones.

He played bad with a better surrounding cast than Maye had.

There’s no denying that the Colts gutted their roster at the trade deadline, particularly offensively. So Jones was in a pretty impossible position on Thursday night against the Texans, and Anthony Richardson won’t be in a much better spot the rest of the way.

But, prior to all those moves, Indianapolis’ offense was fairly loaded. Even after Alec Pierce’s season-ending injury in Week 2, Josh Downs and Keenan Allen were still a better receiving duo than many of the combinations the Patriots have rolled out. Tyler Warren is a weapon at tight end. Jonathan Taylor is arguably a top-5 running back in football. And the Colts had a pretty good offensive line, too.

Daniel Jones couldn’t succeed with that group around him. If he signs with the Patriots, he’s walking into an unstable offensive line, an underwhelming running back room, and a receiving corps currently led by Mack Hollins and DeMario Douglas.

How can Jones be expected to go from the anchor holding back the Indianapolis offense to the savior of New England’s?

He lost his starting job to Tommy DeVito.

Lest we forget, the quarterback that Jones would be replacing with the Patriots is the same one who ran him out of New York in the first place.

DeVito looked bad on Sunday. And he doesn’t look like he’s the answer to New England’s issues down the stretch. But if DeVito was good enough to beat out Jones as the Giants starting quarterback, why should anybody assume that Jones will suddenly be an upgrade over him two years later?

His contract doesn’t make sense for New England.

For all of the on-field concerns that should sound alarm bells for New England, there is one undeniable contractual fact that should keep the Patriots away from signing Jones: he’s owed $10 million guaranteed in 2027.

ESPN & NFL Network insider Ian Rapoport confirmed Friday that whichever team signs Jones will be on the hook for $2 million in 2026 salary owed, and will also be responsible for paying out his $10 million injury guarantee next year.

So, it’s not as if signing Jones is a no-risk, high-reward scenario. It will cost New England legitimate cap space in 2027. Cap space that the team will certainly need as it looks to improve its roster and braces for Maye’s inevitable massive contract extension.

The Patriots are already preparing for the cap crunch that will come from paying both Maye and Christian Gonzalez lucrative contracts. They may not be jumping at the chance to pay out an additional $10 million toward Jones, who will certainly either be the backup or off the team entirely in 2027.

New England should poke around at the options available to it on the free agent quarterback market. But it should avoid Jones at all costs. Building towards the future is a far better option than taking a flyer on Jones, who hasn’t proven he’ll be anything close to a positive addition for the Patriots anyway.

Colin McCarthy

Sports producer

Colin McCarthy is a sports producer who covers Boston’s professional teams and national sports news.

Get the latest Boston sports news

Receive updates on your favorite Boston teams, straight from our newsroom to your inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *