PW Talks with Derf Backderf

PW Talks with Derf Backderf

Derf Backderf came to political cartooning the old fashioned way. A journalism student in college, Backderf (for whom the easily memorable “Derf” is a professional pen name) began his career as a political cartoonist, drawing his syndicated strip The City over a span of 24 years in the ’90s and early 2000s. The strip won Backderf a reputation for both incendiary commentary and offbeat, indie-flavored humor, but it was only when he stepped into longform graphic novels in 2010 that he found his voice as an artist.

After an initial graphic memoir, 2008’s Punk Rock and Trailer Parks, Backderf’s breakout came in 2010 with My Friend Dahmer, a true-life recounting of his high school friendship with the soon-to-be serial killer that was adapted into a 2017 film. After a detour into longform fiction (2015’s Trashed), his career evolution was cemented by 2020’s Kent State: Four Dead in Ohio. Backderf’s first foray into deeply researched historical nonfiction earned him an Eisner Award and topped PW’s 2020 critics’ poll.

His latest book, The Dissidents: Autocrats! Vigilantes! Communists! And Cartoonists! (Abrams ComicArts), was released in September and takes Backderf even further back in American history. It tells the story of the radical cartoonists who worked on the early-20th-century socialist magazine The Masses—and the fates they met in the wake of World War I. Backderf talked with PW at this year’s Small Press Expo about turning history into comics, and the relevance of The Dissidents to our current political moment.

What first drew you to the story of The Dissidents, and the cartoonists of The Masses?

I discovered them when I was in college, and I was just blown away. It was so different from what I was seeing in modern political cartooning at that time, which was all very derivative. When I started doing books, which came pretty late in my career—I was 50 years old before I published my first book—I always had a list of stories I thought would make a good book. The Masses was on there, but I had other stories I wanted to get to first. After Kent State, I got together with my editor, Charlie Kochman, and he said, “Do that one.”

The Dissidents is largely a work of researched nonfiction, but it’s told through a fictional composite protagonist, Joe Hertl. What led to that approach?

I needed a narrator. I needed somebody who could explain the context, why these cartoons were so incendiary, why the government decided they had to crush these cartoonists. I could have done a floating narration, but I did that with Kent State, and I didn’t want to do that again. I wrestled with it, and this is the solution I came up with. It let me add a little of my own experience into this, which is kind of egotistical, probably. It also let me work in the immigrant experience, which was really key to the story—it’s based on my grandmother’s family, because they endured all of that during World War I.

Since this is a book about cartoonists, did you make an attempt to mimic any of the visual style of artists you were depicting?

I very purposely stuck to my own style, which really coalesced, I think, with Kent State. It’s a much more traditional style than what I did earlier [in my career]—back in the ’90s, [when I was] doing these crazy expressionistic, experimental comics. I’ve gotten more traditional since then, because I’m focusing more on the story. I think my style does separate itself from the cartoons I reproduce, and that was a tricky balancing act. Because I did want to showcase those cartoons, and make them stand out a little from what I was doing.

You started work on this book three and a half years ago. Were you prepared for 100-year-old history to become as topical as it did by the time you finished?

Well, didn’t you see it coming? I sure did. When I started it, I thought, this is a warning. But of course, I didn’t finish it until it was too late for warnings. So I don’t know what it is now. It’s important to be reminded that we’ve been here before. It’s worth noting that we pulled out of it before. And really, Kent State is a companion piece. It’s like every 50 years we seem to repeat our dance with autocracy. You can only do that so many times until autocracy wins.

Is there anything about comics that’s particularly well-suited to portraying history?

It’s a difficult genre. There are a lot of minefields with doing historical comics. If you start making stuff up—that’s the big one. When you start to fudge the facts or the timeline to fit your narrative, that’s not how you do it. The story’s there, you just have to find it. You pick a beginning and an end, and then you carefully fill in the blanks.

Is there any part of you that just wants to say “to hell with it,” and stop doing historical comics?

Just make something like everybody else? I think my next book will be a comedy. I just need a break.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *