John C. Foster “Hate House” (2024) – The Horror Bookshelf

John C. Foster “Hate House” (2024) – The Horror Bookshelf

Publication Date: May 21, 2024
Publisher: Encyclopocalypse Publications

One of the coolest things about reviving The Horror Bookshelf when I did was that it coincided with a bunch of authors who were instrumental to the site’s growth in the early years releasing new novels. There’s J. Daniel Stone’s Daubed in Darkness, Jonathan Janz’s Children of the Dark 2: The Night Flyers, and plenty more coming in the rest of the year. Another one that I was really excited for was John C. Foster’s latest novel, Hate House. I distinctly remember the first time I discovered Foster’s work. It was his short story “Mister White”, which appeared in the second volume of Grey Matter Press’ essential Dark Visions anthology series. 

I loved “Mister White”  the first time I read it, but it was one of those stories that took awhile to fully sink in. Shortly after that first reading, I realized I couldn’t stop thinking about “Mister White”. Who the hell is Mister White? Although I guess a more accurate question to ask would be what is Mister White? What the hell did these spies do to wind up in his (its?) crosshairs? Foster would eventually expand on the events of that short story to create the espionage/horror mash-up novel Mister White, which I firmly believe should be considered a modern horror classic. It was that one-two combination of bone-chilling horror and crime noir that led me to fall in love with Foster’s devastating brand of dark fiction and I’ve been a fan ever since. So naturally when I saw Foster would be dropping Hate House this year, I knew I had to get my hands on it! 

In Hate House, reclusive private investigator Megan French is lured from her Philadelphia apartment by the wealthy Abbott, a man who wants her to prove the infamous Hate House is rightfully his. He claims his late, ultra-rich ex-wife Simone Laurent wanted to drive him mad by imprisoning him in isolation on the island for his past transgressions, and so he feels like his suffering earned him the right to claim to the house and the island. Megan’s not really interested in his reasoning – he’s wealthy, he’s paying her, and it’s the sort of job that could offer her the freedom from her own haunted past. The estate and Abbott have been battling each other in court for years and  each have been employing security patrols to keep the other out. Megan agrees to take the job, but it will be unlike any other job she’s had before. Because she will be sharing her time at Hate House with the Laurent estates own investigator, a man named Grady. As Megan and Grady set out to find the truth behind who truly owns Hate House, Megan begins to realize this is more than a simple land dispute. Hate House is home to dark secrets and Megan being hired for this job is more than a coincidence. 

On the surface, the set-up for Hate House seems like a traditional ghost story, but there are many other elements at play. But Foster uses that tradition to give Hate House a personality all of its own, think Richard Matheson’s Hell House, Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House, or High Place in Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s Mexican Gothic. The house was built on an isolated island and while that isolation plays a large role in what happened to Abbott during his time there, Foster engages all of the senses to cultivate the Hate House’s character. One of the earliest depictions of Hate House features this scene

“A breeze might bring her the clean scene of the sea, but here she wallowed in the smell of brackish marsh. Generations of dead clams gave off the sulfurous stink of hard-boiled eggs, amplified by billions of dead and whatever else once lived in the swampy rivers that wound from land toward the Atlantic.” 

As someone who spent their entire life in the Northeast, that one scene instantly transported me into Foster’s story and damn if memories of that smell didn’t come rushing back. Sure, that pungent smell is natural, but it also represents a warning in the context of Hell House – that only bad things await those who venture into its halls. As Megan explores Hate House, it reveals itself as a monument to spite and insanity. Salt-water coming from the pipes, rot consuming the furniture, and a long line of red ochre men smeared on the walls. Hate House and its depiction have a strong New England Gothic influence and readers will definitely feel the chills that permeate throughout its pages.

One of the things I love most about Foster’s writing is not just his ability to blend genres, but also how he’s able to subvert reader expectations. Hate House gleefully bounces between haunted house, gothic and mystery tropes and just when you think you have an idea of where the story is going, Foster unveils a surprise that will make you question everything. Hell, I know I did. Those surprises don’t just pertain to the main narrative, but also the characters as well. Megan is a character I instantly gravitated toward because she embodies the uber-talented, take-no-bullshit private eye that I just can’t get enough of in noir fiction. Throughout Hate House, details of the past she’s trying to outrun come to light and it’s easy to take them at face value. But just like in real life, the truth is often a lot messier. That being said, I loved Megan and her journey. Despite facing very real threats from those who wield more power and resources than her, she never once shies away from danger. 

Hate House is full of dizzying, mind-warping surprises and utilizes atmosphere and secrets to create a gripping story that races towards a stunning conclusion that I’m sure will spark debate among readers. Hate House is a lot like Mister White in that regard. It’s a story that sticks with readers – especially yours truly – and invites theories or imagining possible scenarios. Hate House comes with my highest recommendation and I’m sure I will be cursing Foster for years to come over the anguish this book caused me. I mean that with the utmost respect and as the highest compliment I can give, of course! Pick up a copy of Hate House for a damn good story and experience the dark secrets of Hate House for yourself. 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *