Sergeant accused of drunk driving in fatal crash resigns from State Police

Sergeant accused of drunk driving in fatal crash resigns from State Police

Crime

A State Police internal affairs investigation sustained charges of “serious misconduct” as the department moved to terminate his employment, according to the agency.

Massachusetts State Police Sgt. Scott Quigley is arraigned at Middlesex Superior Court. Mark Stockwell/Boston Herald, Pool

A State Police sergeant resigned from the agency on Monday after an internal affairs investigation sustained findings of “serious misconduct” in a fatal 2023 crash.

Scott Quigley‘s resignation comes as he faces a criminal charge of motor vehicle homicide and a civil wrongful death suit. Prosecutors allege Quigley drunkenly crashed his unmarked police vehicle into a wheelchair van transporting 37-year-old Angelo Schettino, who died a month later from his injuries.

Quigley, who worked for State Police for 15 years, maintains his innocence in the case, his lawyer, Daniel Moynihan, said in a statement Monday. The statement specifically cited State Police’s unwillingness to wait for the criminal case’s outcome and an allegation that the department concluded the investigation without interviewing Quigley.

“The decision to resign results from a lack of confidence that he would receive due process from the Department,” Moynihan wrote.

State Police, however, said Quigley’s decision to resign came as the department began to initiate proceedings to terminate his employment following the results of the investigation. Quigley, who had 14 days to accept or challenge the termination, resigned on Monday, and State Police dishonorably discharged him, the agency said.

The internal investigation sustained several violations of State Police rules and regulations, including conformance to laws, truthfulness, alcoholic beverages, neglect of duty, and unsatisfactory performance, according to State Police.  

“The Department will not tolerate conduct that violates the public trust or undermines the integrity of the Massachusetts State Police,” Col. Geoffrey Noble, the head of State Police, said in a statement. “Every member, regardless of rank or tenure, is held to the highest standards of professionalism and accountability, and those who fail to meet them will face decisive consequences.” 

Man in wheelchair killed in 2023 crash

Quigley left the Middlesex District Attorney’s office just after 3 p.m. on Dec. 12, 2023, to meet with another State Police detective at a nearby restaurant and bar, according to the Commonwealth’s statement of the sase. The two, who ordered light food and a total of six drinks, left after 4:30 p.m. in their separate unmarked police vehicles. 

While driving on Lexington Street in Woburn, Quigley accelerated to 59 mph in a 35-mph area, crossing the centerline and crashing head-on into a wheelchair van traveling in the opposite direction, prosecutors say.

The van, which was traveling under the speed limit, was transporting Schettino, a paraplegic with developmental challenges, from an appointment to his group home, prosecutors wrote in the statement of the case.

Schettino and the van driver were taken to a nearby hospital after the crash. Schettino had no visible wounds, but he has internal injuries that worsened over time, and he died on Jan. 13, 2024, prosecutors say. His official cause of death was blunt force trauma from the crash.

Quigley, meanwhile, was taken to the hospital with head trauma, internal organ damage, and a pelvic fracture. He was on injury leave for eight months afterwards, prosecutors say.

Quigley’s alleged drunk driving not widely known until January 2026 

The hospital measured Quigley’s blood-alcohol content between 0.95 and 0.1 — well above the legal limit for driving in Mass. of 0.08, prosecutors wrote.

But the information about the alleged intoxication was not publicized until January 2026, when prosecutors in a separate Lowell murder trial disclosed the investigation into Quigley, who was the lead investigator. The murder case has been delayed as the case’s judge wrote that Quigley’s criminal case could be “possible impeachment evidence.”

Prosecutors disclosed information about the investigation into Quigley’s crash in more than 140 criminal cases, according to a filing in the murder case.

State Police had suspended Quigley without pay since Feb. 6. A grand jury indicted him March 26 on a motor vehicle homicide charge, with prosecutors saying that Quigley caused the crash through negligence and because he was drunk. His next court date is Dec. 4, with a trial set for February.

Two other members of State Police under criminal investigation in connection with crash

The fallout from Quigley’s crash has entangled at least two other members of State Police, who may have helped cover up that Quigley was drunk at the time of the crash. A Middlesex County judge wrote in a filing that both Lt. Anthony DeLucia and Sgt. Mark Delaney were the subject of a “criminal investigation.”

A report by the Middlesex DA’s Office in April found DeLucia allegedly told another employee that Quigley’s blood-alcohol content was “a 0.11” and told the employee not to repeat that information. State Police suspended DeLucia with pay in April, and he retired in the following weeks. The agency placed Delaney on “restricted duty,” according to a court filing.

The report also found that State Police failed to notify the DA’s office of Quigley’s alleged intoxication in the immediate aftermath of the crash. The Middlesex judge’s filing said no one in the DA’s office was aware of the alleged intoxication until January.

Noble hired an outside consulting firm — 21CP Solutions — to examine the agency’s response to the crash. The firm’s independent review is assessing State Police’s required notifications, escalation procedures, supervisory actions, command-level oversight, documentation and recording standards, and internal coordination, State Police said.

Profile image for Brendan Nordstrom

Brendan Nordstrom

Night Reporter

Brendan is a general assignment reporter for Boston.com, covering crime, education, courts, and more. 

Sign up for the Today newsletter

Get everything you need to know to start your day, delivered right to your inbox every morning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *