Welcome to Speculative Poetry Month! It has been almost 10 years since my first speculative poetry publication in Uncanny Magazine, and in that time the community of writers working on speculative poems has only grown—in size, power, and recognition. Woo!
Within the speculative writing community, determined advocates have pushed through special Hugos for Poetry over the past two years, with the hope of a permanent Hugo, and the Nebulas now have a poem category! And in the literary community, we see more literary poets shifting into topics once considered solely genre—creating new takes on folklore, and then—what a brief step it is—from the natural world to alien landscapes, science to science fiction, and of course modern-day horrors to speculative ones.
But in the wake of this golden age of cross-pollination, comes the actual AI. Those artificial agents that, having sucked down as much writing and Internet prose as they can, now stand ready to regurgitate everything for us. Essentially wave us back to the divans to eat grapes and grow sleepy-brained, while the machines get to do all the fun stuff.
Hell. Naw.
The fun of poetry is the discovery, and the work. The craft. It’s the one thing that the machine can’t get right, because poetic craft grows from the alchemy of lived human experience blending with applied knowledge of how to land emotional truths. In celebration of this very human process, for speculative poetry month, in this essay I’m going to focus on craft and revision.
I am defining speculative poetry as Terese Maison Pierre did this year at Worldcon in Los Angeles. Paraphrasing her, a speculative poem is one that speculates—takes on speculative topics or concepts, shows us new realities in the boundaries of the poem, possibly constructing new forms or diction to embody them. Whether a poem is a speculative poem or not, derives from the kind of work the poem is doing.
Okay, so you want this to be shaped as a poem. Another axis to consider then: is your poem narrative, or lyrical? In a recent seminar I had with the poet Ellen Bass, she suggested that asking this question can be useful to figure out why a poem’s approach isn’t working.
Often speculative poets (having read a lot of speculative fiction, or perhaps having also written a lot of fiction, or both) expect their poems to always read like stories. The urge will be to add more story-like elements. That’s fine for certain poems, but it may not be what the poem wants to do.
The diction for prose can be coiled much less tightly and has a larger word count in which to expand. Meanwhile, poetic language has to do intense work within tight constraints and always sound good while doing it. A poem can make leaps where fiction would still need to lead the reader step by step. A poem can use its volta instead of the traditional narrative climax.
So, if a first draft is not coming together as a narrative poem, it’s possible that instead of adding more narrative elements, you may discover more of the true shape of the poem by approaching it lyrically. Explore the subject with music, rhythm, and sound creating a structure that carries the reader with it, without needing to spell out a narrative.
Reading what you have aloud always helps. Narrative poems will always land better with strong sound and rhythm choices, and the lyric poem requires it. The trick of reading drafts aloud—whether narrative or lyrical—can always catch things that weren’t apparent while you were typing.
After the poem satisfies you sonically, now, look at the poem purely on the page. This is a bit like creative copyediting.
Examine the diction and meaning you have put into these lines. How many times have you used abstractions as a shortcut, counting on the reader to know precisely what is meant without any anchors? Because let’s face it—you and I define love differently. Heartbreak can be good for certain people, bad for others. And grief—there are 999 ways to mourn, and no two people will mourn the same way even for the same person.
Abstraction words placed too soon within a poem come across often like handwaving. At the beginning of a poem, I need to be oriented in the poet’s world. Show me specifics. Is love a home-cooked spaghetti dinner with garlic and Parmesan? Is grief being unable to take a microwave pepperoni pizza out of the freezer, because it was the loved one’s favorite? Let me taste your abstractions. Don’t tell me you are in pain, show me where it hurts.
I often have to take this advice myself. To earn my abstraction words, I too have to build the sensory scaffolding to take the reader there.
Look out for crutch words, or words your brain inserts into your poems all the time because it likes them or likes to rely on them. For some reason, my brain loves the word “the.” In my first drafts, it can’t be “bursting grapes on a vine,” it has to be “THE bursting grape on THE vine.” I go back to my poems all the time removing the’s from the lines. The word “the” doesn’t do much for most images, and except for possibly rhythm or syllable counting reasons, a lot of times you can skip the article “the.”
And only in dire, very intentional circumstances can you end a line on “the.” “The” has no zing of meaning by itself, and only the anticipation of the object or action following it gives a “the” any power. And because at the end of the line, in poetry a “the” could be followed by literally anything on the next line, a line that ends in “the” dilutes the power of the line. Much better to end the line with a word that resonates for the reader—visually or sonically—and then have the poem gather up steam again at the beginning of the next line.
My final tip of the essay has to do with endings. So many times, I have read promising poems (literary or speculative) that build up from a great beginning and then sadly fizzle out, ending too early. Or end confusingly. The final word of a poem, like all those words before line breaks, has to have a resonance, create an echo in the reader’s mind. A poem’s ending can bring you full circle, or land the plane entirely on a new runway, ready to take off again like a touch and go. Either way, the last word is the one bringing it home. Your entire poem is building to that final word, so make it count.
“Okay Betsy,” you say, “but that’s the after part. When my draft is perfect, I am sure then it will end with the right word. What about the messy middle writing phase, when I am trying to make the ending happen? What if I am fizzing out myself? What if my brain mostly likes beginnings?”
One trick Kimiko Hahn taught me that I continue to use, is to rewrite a first draft line by line, backwards. Start with the last line, then add the second to last line, and so on until the poem ends on its beginning line.
This technique works much more often than it should. I may find my ending in the beginning that way. Or as I re-type line by line, I may find the true beginning of the poem in one of those throwaway lines embedded in the central mass of words, and start writing a new poetic ending from there. The joy of poetry writing is in the discovery, finding out what the poem wants to be. Sometimes your poems are wiser than you, and to shield you they come out in reverse.
Trust your brain. Trust revision. Trust the poem—it will show you how it should go, as you write yourself through this process.
Now, write those poems!
Betsy Aoki is a poet, fiction writer, and videogame producer whose work has appeared in Asimov’s Science Fiction, Beneath Ceaseless Skies, Nightmare, Strange Horizons, Uncanny Magazine, and most recently Critical Role: The Mighty Nein-Stories Untold anthology. Her debut poetry collection, Breakpoint, was a National Poetry Series finalist and winner of the Patricia Bibby First Book Award. She has received Hugo Awards for her work as poetry editor of Uncanny Magazine.
