New England Patriots
“If you’re just judging it by first year in, I can’t think of a trade that has just gone worse in every single respect from the moment we’ve gotten him.”
A.J. Brown has struggled in his first season with the Patriots. (Danielle Parhizkaran/Globe Staff)
Boston is no stranger to getting burned by franchise-altering trades in the past, be it Babe Ruth, Mookie Betts, Jeff Bagwell, Ken Dryden, and more.
But Bill Simmons believes the Patriots’ decision to give up valuable draft capital to pry A.J. Brown from the Philadelphia Eagles warrants a spot among the worst trades in his market’s history.
During the latest episode of his podcast, The Ringer founder and longtime Boston sports scribe harped on Brown’s lack of production since arriving in New England in June.
Brown has been limited to just four games so far this season due to several injuries, including a high ankle sprain, a nagging knee issue, and a hamstring setback that led to the Patriots pulling him from Sunday’s 35-10 loss to the Lions in Germany.
When he has been out on the gridiron, Brown hasn’t looked like the All-Pro wideout that New England thought it was getting when it traded two picks (including a 2028 first-rounder) to Philly to land him.
So far this season, Brown has only recorded 11 catches off 26 targets for 128 yards while also getting knocked for several uncharacteristic drops.
For Simmons, the decision to trade for an older wideout like Brown with clear red flags regarding his health is looking like a disaster in hindsight.
“Then we have this A.J. Brown sub-plot where they decide to play him this week because what could go wrong with a guy is not 100 percent on a terrible field in Munich, right? What could go wrong,” Simmons said. “They keep him in where it’s 28-3 or whatever it is. He’s still out there, and finally, of course, he gets hurt, catches one ball.
“And this has been one of the worst trades in Boston sports history. If you’re just judging it by first year in, I can’t think of a trade that has just gone worse in every single respect from the moment we’ve gotten him.”
Before his arrival in New England, Brown was one of the most impactful wideouts of his generation, surpassing 1,000 receiving yards in six of his first seven years in the league.
But warning signs emerged regarding Brown’s health.
In an interview with Yahoo Sports’ Jori Epstein, Patriots executive vice president of player personnel Eliot Wolf said that he was aware that Brown had a “degenerative knee condition” prior to the Patriots trading for him.
“It’s a factor, but we examined him,” Wolf told Epstein. “He’s got a knee that has some wear and tear that we were aware of. Our training staff and medical staff signed off on it.
That knee has hindered Brown so far during his time in Foxborough, and could continue to limit him for the remainder of his career.
“We get him, and they’re like, ‘Oh, you know, he has a degenerative knee.” Or like, ‘Oh, well, his knee’s okay this year, right?” All the Philly fans are like, “He either quit last year or he has a [expletive]-up knee. It’s one or the other.’ It’s like, oh, that doesn’t sound great,” Simmons said. “And then he shows up and gets hurt in an hour.
“He’s on my fantasy team, so that’s been fun. And he’s come back twice, and each time he’s come back, it’s gone horribly. … He’s N’Keal Harry.”
Conor Ryan is a staff writer covering the Bruins, Celtics, Patriots, and Red Sox for Boston.com, a role he has held since 2023.
Get the latest Boston sports news
Receive updates on your favorite Boston teams, straight from our newsroom to your inbox.
