Lena Dunham’s “Famesick” Is a Cautionary Tale of Filmmakers Doing TV

Lena Dunham’s “Famesick” Is a Cautionary Tale of Filmmakers Doing TV

Early in Lena Dunham’s memoir “Famesick,” she describes living back in her artist-parents’ Tribeca loft after college and becoming involved with an informal collective of young New York filmmakers. During that period, she developed her ultra-low-budget feature film, “Tiny Furniture,” casting relatives, friends, and acquaintances and filming in the family loft. The movie was accepted at the 2010 South by Southwest film festival and became an instant success, winning the Grand Jury Prize. What followed, in short order, was Dunham signing on to make the HBO series “Girls,” which ran for six seasons and became one of the cultural touchstones of the twenty-tens. “Famesick”—a feast of keen observations and psychological insights delivered vividly, with candor and wit—details the many issues that arose in the wake of the show’s success, including the rapid onset of Dunham’s celebrity, the series of illnesses that she endured, and the connection between those seemingly disparate experiences. Her narrative is frankly and stringently personal, but it also provides a wide-angle view of show business itself, and of a fundamental artistic conflict within it: the cost of moving from the freedom of independent filmmaking to the corporate demands of TV.

The first twist in the story is that Dunham had no intention of making “Girls” or any other television series. After the triumph of “Tiny Furniture” at SXSW, “emails began pouring in—from sales agents, from talent agents, from managers, from producers”—and she had no idea how to respond or what to do. Her mother, Laurie Simmons, had a connection and found her an agent—a prominent one, Peter Benedek, at the agency that he co-founded, United Talent Agency. He brought Dunham out to Los Angeles, where, after a couple of weeks of insubstantial meetings at a variety of companies, they went to HBO, where she met executives whom she found sympathetic and eager to work with her. When Dunham, who was then twenty-three, went to Los Angeles, she had a general idea of what she was hoping for—and what she wasn’t. “At that point, I had no sense that television was something I wanted to make,” she writes, “but I’d heard it was a job that could sustain an indie film habit—a job in a writer’s room seemed, as far as jobs went, like one I could handle.” But things quickly changed at the HBO meeting, where she was asked, “What would you want to make?”

Taken by surprise, Dunham spontaneously described what would become “Girls.” She wrote the idea up that very night and submitted it the next day; within hours, HBO offered her a deal to write the pilot. The executives, however, didn’t just send her home to write; they also hooked her into the corporate system within which she’d be writing. “HBO told me that I would be set up with something called a ‘supervisor,’ ” she writes, and they arranged phone meetings with their selected batch of “candidates.” She connected with the first one she spoke with, the screenwriter Jenni Konner, and offered Konner the job at once. The role of the supervisor, Dunham writes, was “a kind of mentor, someone who helped you if you had never written TV, to understand the invisible but mighty set of rules that governed the form.” A few weeks later, Dunham went to Los Angeles to work with Konner, who explained the show-making formula: “She introduced me to ideas like A and B stories, inciting incidents, and comic set pieces.” Described this way, the lessons sound like marching orders.

Even before submitting the script for the pilot, Dunham was asked to write four episodes along with it. In September, the studio decided to make the pilot, and the shoot was scheduled for November. This, Dunham writes, “gave us two months to cast, hire crew, scout locations, build sets, and a million other things that hadn’t yet occurred to me since I’d never made anything outside my own house.” She was ready to let the process take over her life (“There was nowhere else I needed to be”) and eager to make the series: “If I loved making movies, then making TV, I figured, must be like a movie that never ends. And what could be better than that?” The be-careful-what-you-wish-for part came quickly. The production was set up at Silvercup Studios, in Queens. Dunham had an office there and, at times, she felt lost: “Often, when I closed the door, I didn’t know what to do with myself. I would sit there alone, wondering how a person with a sign like that on their door used their time.” She had entered a machine that was running on its own, assembled by people who assembled such machines for a living, and she had to find a way to fit her ideas and herself into it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *