Tally Brown “graced stages of all sizes and delighted audiences of all types,” Melissa Anderson writes in our November 19, 2026, issue. As seen in Rosa von Praunheim’s 1979 documentary Tally Brown, New York, she was an “indelible figure: short and rotund, outrageously bewigged,” with “gapped teeth and mile-long false eyelashes.” Anderson’s essay, occasioned by a recent restoration of the film, conveys Brown’s contagious sense of pride in her hedonism, her work, and above all her hometown, both the scrappy New York of her youth and the queer nightlife in the city where she spent much of her adulthood.
Anderson has been a film critic for more than two decades. Her reviews are a first port of call for many moviegoers upon leaving the theater: lively, dense with reference, and, it seems, always correct. For nine years Anderson was the film editor and lead film critic at 4Columns; though the website stopped publishing earlier this year, her vast archive there is still available online, full of her characteristically sharp, tightly woven opinions on contemporary movies and repertory screenings, with occasional wide-ranging essays on, for example, Jane Fonda in the 1970s. (Her book The Hunger collects over a decade of her film writing.) She was the film editor at Time Out New York and the senior film critic at the Village Voice and is currently a columnist at Film Comment. For many years she wrote about film for Artforum, and she is a regular contributor to Bookforum. Her monograph on David Lynch’s Inland Empire was published in 2021. Over email this week she tried to convince me that there’s no point in being alarmist about the fate of cinema.
Nawal Arjini: You are a great chronicler of the filmic and literary representations of New York’s twentieth-century queer underbelly. As the city has gotten “cleaner and shinier,” as you write, and as queer life has increasingly entered the mainstream, where in New York do you see these scenes persist, or where are new ones beginning?
Melissa Anderson: When I moved to New York, in 1996, I spent countless hours in Manhattan dyke bars and clubs, which were then flourishing: Meow Mix (later to relocate to Brooklyn and become Cattyshack), Crazy Nanny’s, the Cubbyhole, Rubyfruit, and Henrietta Hudson, among others. Of these stalwarts, only the Cubbyhole and Henrietta’s remain (and Ginger’s, in Brooklyn, which opened in 2000). I am no longer a habitué, but I always have a good time during my occasional visits. I am also no longer young and not as much of a nocturnal creature as I once was, with an instinct for where things are happening. But I am fortunate to be close friends with three lesbians who are about thirty years my junior—they are my “youth spies,” to use John Waters’s term, and they keep me au courant. Sometimes, we make discoveries together: two months ago, after a screening we all attended at e-flux, we happened upon a fabulous lesbian sports bar in Clinton Hill, Athena Keke’s. I aim to be like Tally Brown, who was a lifelong New Yorker and loved the city with a tremendous passion but abhorred nostalgia. She never thought that the city was better, was at its peak, when she was in her twenties and thirties. She knew the city was constantly reborn and reenergized by young people.
You spent many years as the film editor and critic at 4Columns, an arts site with firm constraints—a thousand words, every week. Your previous work at Time Out also involved even more brutal space restrictions; did having to condense your thoughts this way shape the way you think about movies, or writing? And how did it feel to write in a relatively unconstrained fashion for us?
How I think about a particular movie has never been affected by word count, which, in the twenty-plus years I’ve been a film critic, has typically ranged between 200 and 1,200 words. And no matter the length of the piece, I always want a robust intro and outro, so I will spend too much time fussing over ledes and kickers. But the more words I have, the more space I can devote to widening the discussion, expounding on certain points, or, in the case of writing about an older film, providing more historical background. Thus, for the New York Review piece on Tally Brown, New York, I could devote some time to talking about the career of Rosa von Praunheim, the documentary’s German director, and his fascination with NYC.
A recent essay in n+1 argued that the “intellectual situation” is one of literary necrophilia: all anyone is reading these days are old books, partly because it’s all anyone is publishing. Repertory screening is not a new feature of cinematic culture, especially in New York, but is there an analogous situation in moviegoing—a turn away from the present?
I am elated to report that this is not the case with moviegoing in New York City. On a recent Tuesday, for example, I went to a 1:00 PM showing at Film at Lincoln Center of Possible Love, the latest by the Korean director Lee Chang-dong. I had thought I might be one of a handful of people there, but I was one of about fifty. This is not an isolated incident. It seems that no matter when I see a new release—weekends or weekdays; morning, midday, or night—the spectators will always number, at the very least, in the double digits.
Not to belabor that comparison, but part of that argument was that novels used to be edited and shepherded through publication in a way they aren’t anymore. Of modern Hollywood’s many problems, is that one—that filmmakers or actors have less guidance than before?
If we’re talking specifically about Hollywood—that is, films backed by the major studios, or what’s left of them—then I’d argue that the problem is that there’s too much guidance, in that these movies have to follow a rigid template. Biopics that hit all of the same beats, for instance, or films—remakes, sequels, prequels—that exist solely as an extension of intellectual property. But in New York, this kind of cinema is a mere fraction of what’s available.
All American filmmakers, particularly those working independently, face the same struggle as their predecessors: getting funded. And yet every year excellent films by independent, US-based filmmakers that are true to their makers’ visions are released: in 2026 alone, that would include Steven Soderbergh’s The Christophers, John Early’s Maddie’s Secret, Lucio Castro’s Drunken Noodles, Jane Schoenbrun’s Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything, among many others. I don’t wish to sound too sanguine. But since the medium began, bad or mediocre films have always outnumbered good or great ones.
Would you talk a bit about the critical approach you often take, of following actors through projects, rather than directors? It seems like the way so many more casual moviegoers decide what to watch but not many cinephiles, for some reason.
The fabulous term “acteurism” was coined by Dave Kehr, a longtime critic turned film curator, for a series he launched at MoMA in 2014 organized around the concept. He described the program as “devoted to actors who were able to develop their screen personalities with sufficient consistency and vivacity that they themselves became vehicles of meaning in their movies.” This was an especially helpful idea as I was writing a monograph on David Lynch’s Inland Empire, his final feature film and also his most labyrinthine. While never wishing to minimize Lynch, a director I revere, I thought it might be more fruitful to look at Laura Dern, Inland Empire’s star and a frequent Lynch collaborator, as the film’s coauthor. At the very least, what Dern does in this frequently confounding movie helps make it legible, lucid.
And although he never used the term, the incomparable gay cult film critic Boyd McDonald was also an acteurist partisan. In a review collected in his 1985 collection, Cruising the Movies, he waggishly writes, referring to the actor Richard Widmark, “He demonstrates the importance of the movie star over the movie and thus the importance of star reviews over mere movie reviews, with their constant complaints about plot.” Those words are never far from my mind whenever I’m writing about a film toward which I’m ambivalent but that boasts a performance that intrigues me, as was the case with Léa Seydoux in David Cronenberg’s Crimes of the Future from 2022.
Based on anecdotal evidence, younger cinephiles seem to have more of an acteurist bent. At recent tributes to actresses like Diane Keaton (at Walter Reade) and María Félix (at MoMA), for example, I was thrilled to be surrounded by so many movie lovers under the age of thirty-five in these high holy temples of cinema. As Barthes would have it in “The Face of Garbo”—perhaps the acteurist urtext—the visages of these performers “plunged [us] into the deepest ecstasy.”
