Ronald Malfi “Small Town Horror” (2024) – The Horror Bookshelf

Ronald Malfi “Small Town Horror” (2024) – The Horror Bookshelf

Publication Date: June 4, 2024
Publisher: Titan Books
As a horror fan, I have an appreciation for just about every subgenre under the sun. However – like most horror fans I’m sure – there are certain styles of horror that speak to me on a deeper level, that move me and go beyond just general enjoyment. I’m an absolute sucker for atmospheric, character-driven horror and if there’s an emotional component at work, even better. There’s something about those types of stories that completely mesmerize me and I’m constantly chasing that high of discovering a new one, whether it be a novel or a film. When it comes to atmospheric horror, particularly in books, few do it better than Ronald Malfi in my opinion.

Malfi’s novels have been consistently wrecking my emotions for years now, especially his 2016 novel The Night Parade. A novel set as a deadly disease called Wanderer’s Folly ravages the country, it follows a man named David and his daughter Ellie as they travel across the country avoiding dangers in a quest for safety. I read that novel a little bit before my daughter was born and goddamn if Malfi didn’t make me cry quite a few times during that book. But that’s what makes Malfi’s books so great – he writes compelling characters that readers will either fall in love with, relate to in some way, or at the very least need to see how their stories end. The other constant is a palpable dread that looms over both his characters and his readers. Those elements have always been present in Malfi’s work, but they continually reach new heights, especially in his current run of novels for Titan – Come with Me, Black Mouth, and now Small Town Horror.

In Small Town Horror, Andrew Larimer is building the perfect life. He is quickly climbing the ladder at his New York law firm and is starting a family with the love of his life, Rebecca. It’s everything Andrew wants, but only months into the pregnancy he begins to experience fears about the pregnancy. It’s only natural as a new parent to be scared, but his nightmares around the pregnancy and his growing unease are threatening to consume him. After confiding in his wife and racking up big wins at the firm, it seems that Andrew is finally overcoming the fears that have plagued him for the past nine months. However, on one of the biggest nights of his life he receives a late-night phone call from his childhood friend Dale, who says he needs his help and begs him to return to Kingsport.

Dale’s frantic pleas convince Andrew to return to his childhood home for the first time in decades. While he’s there to help Dale, he reunites with his other childhood friends: Eric, who is following in his father’s footsteps as the town sheriff; his childhood sweetheart Tig who never did get to venture outside of Kingsport like she dreamed and took over her family’s business; and Meach, whose life has been consumed by drugs and alcohol and the belief that the group’s cursed. Because something happened one terrible night 20 years ago that has bound the friends in secrecy. Now they’re forced to confront the horrors of that night because the past never truly dies.

Characters have always been a driving force of Malfi’s novels and one of the things I loved most about Small Town Horror was the way Malfi portrayed the group dynamics between the five members of the core friend group the novel focuses on. Too often with stories that feature someone returning to their childhood home, it depicts the characters falling into familiar roles with maybe minor changes along the way. They’re essentially just older versions of the people they were, allowing them to pick up their friendships where they left off, no matter how many years have passed. Malfi avoids those pitfalls by skillfully balancing the familiarity these characters have with one another with the awkwardness of trying to reconnect after decades apart. Andrew’s interactions with Meach are a perfect representation of this concept. Andrew reminisces about meeting Meach for the first time and how they saved a bird together and he has a difficult time reconciling that version of Meach with the one he catches squatting in his childhood home. Little moments like that perfectly capture that even though they were close once, the passage of time has made them relative strangers now, bound only by their shared secret and little else.

Speaking of little moments, Malfi utilizes those with masterful execution throughout Small Town Horror to create truly memorable moments. I don’t want to give any of these away as that thrill of discovery is what elevated this novel into one of my favorite reads this year. What I can say is there are numerous moments throughout the novel that seem almost abstract or inconsequential, until Malfi incorporates them back into the novel much later to devastating effect. There was actually one moment in the novel that actually had me say “Get the fuck outta here!” out loud and take a minute to process. Not because it was unbelievable, but because when that final puzzle piece clicked into place, I realized that Malfi had duped me in the best possible way. These gradual reveals illustrate how tightly plotted this novel is and uncovering each of these connections makes for a rich reading experience.

Small Town Horror is a masterful novel that more than lives up to its title, with Malfi unleashing long-buried secrets that cut a path of destruction through the lives of everyone involved in that fateful night 20 years ago. Utilizing that inciting incident along with the unpleasant side of small-town life, Malfi creates the perfect storm of paranoia and guilt that feeds the sense of foreboding that hangs over the unfolding of the narrative. It also raises the question: Is there truly something supernatural happening in Kingsport or is it simply a bunch of coincidences exacerbated by their collective guilt? It’s no secret that I’m a huge Malfi fan and this is another stellar entry into his body of work. If you enjoy atmospheric horror, Small Town Horror is not to be missed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *