Joe Root’s return as England Test captain is one of the biggest U-turns in recent cricket history.
Just four years ago, the Yorkshireman stepped away from the role after one of the toughest periods of his career, admitting the demands of leading the side had become ‘very unhealthy’ and left him emotionally drained.
In the aftermath, few expected him to wear the captain’s blazer again.
Instead, Root flourished without the burden of leadership, producing the finest batting spell of his career and cementing his place among the greatest Test players the game has ever seen.
But following Ben Stokes’ retirement after England’s series defeat to New Zealand in June, the ECB have made a dramatic decision.
Rather than ushering in another new era under an inexperienced captain, they have turned back to the man who knows the job better than anyone.
It is a bold move, but one the governing body clearly believes offers England their best chance of recovering from a worrying slide in red-ball cricket.
Root returns having captained England on a record 65 occasions and with more experience than any player available to the selectors.
His first spell brought memorable highs, including series victories over South Africa and Sri Lanka, but also ended in disappointment as England struggled for consistency.
Joe Root is replacing Ben Stokes as England Test captain and will work under Stephen Fleming
|
GETTY
By the time he resigned in 2022, the team had won just one of their previous 17 Tests, prompting a complete overhaul that saw Stokes become captain and Brendon McCullum arrive as head coach.
Now, however, England find themselves searching for another reset.
The team have lost eight of their last 12 Tests, beginning with a drawn home series against India before suffering a crushing Ashes defeat in Australia and then surrendering another series to New Zealand.
With Pakistan arriving next month, followed by a challenging winter tour of South Africa and a home Ashes series against Australia next summer, the ECB have opted for experience rather than another gamble.
Root’s appointment has also coincided with the arrival of Stephen Fleming as England’s new Test head coach.
Joe Root previously quit as England captain back in 2022
|
GETTY
The former New Zealand captain replaces McCullum, although he will not officially begin work until after the Pakistan series.
Marcus Trescothick will oversee the side on an interim basis before Fleming takes charge ahead of December’s tour of South Africa.
The pairing of Root and Fleming is viewed as central to England’s attempt to rebuild.
Fleming is widely regarded as one of cricket’s outstanding coaches after an 18-year spell with Chennai Super Kings, while his 111 Test appearances for New Zealand and county experience with Middlesex, Yorkshire and Nottinghamshire have earned him enormous respect within the game.
Root believes the partnership can help England return to the top.
Joe Root is a modern-day England cricket legend and still has more to give
| REUTERS
“It is a great honour and privilege to be asked to be England Men’s Test captain again,” he said.
“The Test captaincy is a difficult but hugely rewarding job and, after enjoying a brief taste of it again working with Baz McCullum last month, I am excited to lead this next generation of players forward.
“The opportunity to do that alongside Stephen is also a huge motivator.
“He has proved over a long period of time that he is an exceptional leader with a great knowledge of the game, and I am looking forward to working with him and helping to build a winning environment.”
Fleming has also made it clear that restoring England’s fortunes will require balancing immediate success with long-term planning.
“I’m incredibly excited to be joining England as Test coach,” he said.
“It’s one of the most prestigious coaching positions in world cricket and I am honoured to be appointed.
“Of course, the ambition is always to win now. But equally, it’s about ensuring the team is well placed for the medium and long-term future.
“There is a lot of young talent in and around the team and our aim is to help them fulfil their potential as world-class cricketers.”
The ECB insist Root’s second spell will be very different from his first.
Stephen Fleming has been appointed as the new head coach of England
|
GETTY
Managing director Rob Key believes the extraordinary pressures of captaining during the Covid era contributed significantly to the exhaustion that ultimately forced Root to step aside.
He also feels England now have a far stronger support structure around their captain than existed four years ago, allowing Root to concentrate on leading the team rather than carrying every responsibility himself.
Not everyone is convinced, however.
Former England batter Mark Butcher has criticised the appointment, describing it as ‘a retrograde step’ and arguing that Root’s batting reached another level after relinquishing the captaincy.
He believes England missed an opportunity to appoint a younger long-term leader, warning that asking Root to shoulder the responsibility again could affect the form that has established him as the second-highest run-scorer in Test history.
The ECB, though, clearly see it differently.
Their priority is navigating one of the most demanding periods English cricket has faced in years, with Pakistan, South Africa and Australia all lying ahead.
Rather than placing that responsibility on an untested captain, they have chosen the safest pair of hands available.
Whether Root’s remarkable return proves to be a masterstroke or a nostalgic gamble will become clear over the months ahead. For now, however, he’s the only true man for the job.
