A fresh true-crime nightmare is on the way, and this one digs into one of the most infamous serial killer cases in U.S. history. David Arquette (Scream) and Nick Stahl (Disturbing Behavior) are set to star in Green River Killer, a new thriller inspired by the real-life hunt for murderer Gary Ridgway. Production has already wrapped in Washington and Idaho, with the film aiming to blend gritty procedural storytelling with psychological horror.

From left: David Arquette, Nick Stahl, Vincent Kartheiser and Rainey Qualley

A case that haunts the detectives as much as the audience

Directed by Johnny J. Tabor (Winter: Battleground) from a script by Timothy Michael Hayes (Mary), Green River Killer is set in the Pacific Northwest in the early 1980s. The story follows two detectives, played by Arquette and Stahl, as they spiral deeper into a years-long investigation that consumes their careers and lives. The killer they’re chasing is the kind of predator who can disappear into everyday life—“a man who is no one and everyone,” as the official synopsis puts it.

As the detectives close in, the line between justice and obsession starts to blur, pushing them into darker and more morally dangerous territory. It’s the sort of setup that feels tailor-made for fans of films like Zodiac and Seven—only this time, the horror is rooted in the very real shadow of the Green River case.

The cast around Arquette and Stahl is stacked with genre and character-actor favorites, including Vincent Kartheiser(Mad Men), Rainey Qualley (Shut In), Julie Ann Emery (Better Call Saul), Robert Belushi (According to Jim), Kevin Makely (Any Bullet Will Do), Lew Temple (The Third Saturday in October), and Costas Mandylor (Saw VI). Actor Mitchell Bourke (One Perfect Match) appears as none other than Ted Bundy, whose real-life involvement with the Green River investigation has been documented in books and interviews over the years. 

The real Green River Killer

The film takes its title from the nickname given to Gary Leon Ridgway, the truck painter who became known as the Green River Killer. Ridgway was convicted of murdering 49 women—most of them sex workers or otherwise vulnerable women—between 1982 and 1998 in the Pacific Northwest. He was arrested in 2001 after DNA evidence finally tied him to the killings and has been described as one of the most prolific serial killers in American history, with investigators suspecting his real victim count could be much higher.

Bodies were frequently found near or in the Green River in Washington State, giving the killer his notorious moniker and leaving a psychic scar on the region that’s still felt today. That lingering trauma is exactly what the film’s director says drew him to the project.

“Not to glorify a killer”

Speaking about the film, Tabor told Deadline, “What drew me to this story was how long it haunted those who lived it.”

He went on to explain that investigators spent decades carrying the weight of an apparently endless case and that his goal with Green River Killer is to focus on the people who refused to give up—honoring the work of law enforcement and the memory of the victims rather than turning the murderer into some kind of anti-hero. Working with production company Macova Media, Tabor frames the story as a tribute to those who fought for justice and to the lives that were stolen.

According to Tabor, the ensemble cast threw themselves into that grounded, human approach, aiming to bring an emotional truth to a story that many in the Pacific Northwest still remember all too well.

True crime meets horror

For horror fans, Green River Killer sits in that unsettling space where true crime and genre storytelling bleed together. You’ve got:

• A real-world monster whose crimes are almost too brutal to comprehend
• An obsessive detective story that risks devouring its protagonists
• A backdrop of foggy Pacific Northwest locations that already feel cinematic and eerie
• The added wrinkle of Ted Bundy showing up within the narrative, reflecting how the real investigation once sought insight from another serial killer

There’s no release date yet, and distribution details haven’t been announced, but with production complete and a cast like this, expect Green River Killer to generate plenty of buzz as it moves through post-production and toward release.

Listen to the ‘Eye On Horror Podcast’